I had totally the opposite experience. The recoil pad on my stock started tearing apart. I contacted McMillan and they said it would be $175 to repair with shipping because they would have to repaint the stock. I took it to a local gunsmith, and when he looked at it, he thought they had put on the wrong size recoil pad and that led to the issue. Anyway, it cost me less to have him replace the recoil pad and bed the action than it would have to send it back to McMillan to just replace the recoil pad.
The thing was that they didn't even offer to have me ship it back and take a look at it. They just quoted me the price and left it at that. For what I spent on that stock, I expected more... especially when I kept it even though I was sent the wrong color.
I'll save Old Town Canoe for another day...