Starting Gun Dogs vs. The Demands of Family Life

[VomSteinbruch]

The off switch is because people make there dogs neurotic and dont train them.

The “off switch,” which is closely related to stimulus threshold, is largely genetic. No amount of training can fully create it if it is not already present to some degree. A dog must have at least a solid genetic foundation for mental stability.

Some skilled trainers are able to mask a dog’s inherited neurotic tendencies and create what appears to be an “off switch,” at least on the surface. However, it often reveals itself in unexpected situations.

What they are really doing is conditioning the dog to behave in specific ways in specific contexts through reward and correction. The dog learns that certain environments or situations act as mental boundaries, restricting certain behaviors, and it accepts those boundaries. For example, whining in the crate or in a blind is not allowed, so the dog suppresses the behavior, even though the underlying urge remains due to a low stimulus threshold, which is largely genetic.

As the dog matures and the trainer introduces more of these “mental boundaries,” the dog adjusts its behavior accordingly. However, if the dog is not naturally level-headed, it will struggle to regulate itself in situations where those boundaries have not been clearly established. That’s when things can fall apart.

No training truly fixes this: it is more of a management technique developed by experienced trainers.

You can sometimes see this in dogs sitting quietly in a duck blind. On the surface, they appear calm, but it is often clear that they are tense underneath. An unfamiliar stimulus can trigger a sudden release of that internal pressure, and the dog may become uncontrollable, at least temporarily.

I’ve witnessed this firsthand during a test where a driven hunt was being simulated. A group of dogs was lined up along a forest road, and the requirement was that each dog remain lying down and quiet. Barking would result in disqualification.

A handful of hunters and beaters began working perpendicular to our line in the woods, creating noise by striking bushes and trees with poles. There was a dog next to me that got up as soon as the intensity of the noise increased. At first, it began to whine very softly, which alone would have cost it points, but as the beaters approached closer, started shouting, and firing blanks, the dog completely lost control. It broke, ran toward the beaters, and started barking at them.
The dog ultimately failed the test.

The owner later said that she had spent a significant amount of time preparing for this portion of the test and had managed to get the dog to remain quiet under controlled conditions. However, as soon as something unfamiliar occurred, the dog’s “off switch”, which had only been developed on the surface, fell apart.

 

[KurtR]

The “off switch,” which is closely related to stimulus threshold, is largely genetic. No amount of training can fully create it if it is not already present to some degree. A dog must have at least a solid genetic foundation for mental stability.

Some skilled trainers are able to mask a dog’s inherited neurotic tendencies and create what appears to be an “off switch,” at least on the surface. However, it often reveals itself in unexpected situations.

What they are really doing is conditioning the dog to behave in specific ways in specific contexts through reward and correction. The dog learns that certain environments or situations act as mental boundaries, restricting certain behaviors, and it accepts those boundaries. For example, whining in the crate or in a blind is not allowed, so the dog suppresses the behavior, even though the underlying urge remains due to a low stimulus threshold, which is largely genetic.

As the dog matures and the trainer introduces more of these “mental boundaries,” the dog adjusts its behavior accordingly. However, if the dog is not naturally level-headed, it will struggle to regulate itself in situations where those boundaries have not been clearly established. That’s when things can fall apart.

No training truly fixes this: it is more of a management technique developed by experienced trainers.

You can sometimes see this in dogs sitting quietly in a duck blind. On the surface, they appear calm, but it is often clear that they are tense underneath. An unfamiliar stimulus can trigger a sudden release of that internal pressure, and the dog may become uncontrollable, at least temporarily.

I’ve witnessed this firsthand during a test where a driven hunt was being simulated. A group of dogs was lined up along a forest road, and the requirement was that each dog remain lying down and quiet. Barking would result in disqualification.

A handful of hunters and beaters began working perpendicular to our line in the woods, creating noise by striking bushes and trees with poles. There was a dog next to me that got up as soon as the intensity of the noise increased. At first, it began to whine very softly, which alone would have cost it points, but as the beaters approached closer, started shouting, and firing blanks, the dog completely lost control. It broke, ran toward the beaters, and started barking at them.
The dog ultimately failed the test.

The owner later said that she had spent a significant amount of time preparing for this portion of the test and had managed to get the dog to remain quiet under controlled conditions. However, as soon as something unfamiliar occurred, the dog’s “off switch”, which had only been developed on the surface, fell apart.

First that isn’t an off switch that is called being steady. And she didn’t train ithe dog enough is why the dog broke.

Off switch is coming in the house and laying down and doing nothing. Not pacing around and not barking or just plain acting a fool.

people over stimulate the dogs and then don’t enforce obedience at home then try to be hard ass in the field and it confuses the dog.

Dogs that are genetically neurotic are not bred as they don’t succeed at the top levels . Everyone knows what dogs are noisy and who creeps what faults they have and they have to be really good to over look some like national field champion good. Cosmo was a noisy dog but go back and look at pedigrees and you find him a lot because he was a hammer. The right female would take that out of the pups maybe but you put him with another dragon buckle up. But then he could go lay on the couch and do nothing all day.

 

[VomSteinbruch]

don’t enforce obedience

So you need to enforce obedience to get the dog “off switch”?

Which is better, a dog that needs to be made calm down through obedience or a dog that calms down naturally without oversight?

The Inability to naturally turn on off switch is directly related to a dog’s inability to control itself in unpredictable situations. If you need to train a dog for all possible scenarios due to her low stimulus threshold that ain’t no good dawg. It’s character flaw and it only can be concealed by obedience.

 

[KurtR]

So you need to enforce obedience to get the dog “off switch”?

Which is better, a dog that needs to be made calm down through obedience or a dog that calms down naturally without oversight?

The Inability to naturally turn on off switch is directly related to a dog’s inability to control itself in unpredictable situations. If you need to train a dog for all possible scenarios due to her low stimulus threshold that ain’t no good dawg. It’s character flaw and it only can be concealed by obedience.

Both play a factor. You show the dog what is acceptable and they learn how to relax because they know they can.

Have you ever got to see a fc or afc or grand dog run and then see how they are off the line?

This isn’t just my experience this is guys who have had there hands on hundreds and some thousands of dogs through their career. People like Danny farmer and pat burns have talked about it extensively.

I have only run one national event and getting to see over 900 dogs in one spot you get to watch and learn a lot about dog behavior.

 

[el_jefe_pescado]

This thread is a gold mine. I really appreciate everyone taking the time to chime in.

 

[JGood]

I know this thread is more about the family/hunting dynamic, but if you decide to ignore the good advice in this thread about not getting a dog, here’s some more unsolicited advice.

There are a bunch of hot terms breeders use that are red flags for me and I personally would stay away from. They use these terms as marketing to people who don’t know any better. I’m not saying if a breeder uses these terms they necessarily have bad dogs. I’m just saying they usually have bad dogs.

1. Off-switch
2. For the foot hunter
3. Closeworking
4. Gentlemen’s hunting dog
5. Any reference to a the history of the breed and how the breeder wants to get back to that…looking at you Lewellyn breeders…
6. Any breeder who has 6 dogs or less in their program.
7. Anything disparaging about field trials like “we breed for hunters, not trailers” or “I don’t like high strung trial dogs” or “trial dogs are too much for the house”
8. Any references or weight on the dogs being imported as though that is a merrit.
9. Anything that references European style of hunting like low tail or creeping.
10. Anyone who disparages steady dogs
11. Anyone who says they breed well rounded dogs.
12. Versatile dog breeders who honestly believe their dogs are the best at everything. I promise you their dogs are not competing at Ames Plantation and National Retriever trials

 

[VomSteinbruch]

Both play a factor. You show the dog what is acceptable and they learn how to relax because they know they can.

Of course both are factor, but genetics is the foundation. It dictates most of the outcomes and the only thing we can do is either expand on it through training or conceal it through training.

When someone tells me his dog has off switch, my question was it mostly achieved through training or the dog happens to be naturally calm.

One may ask, what is exactly the different between the dog that off switches via training and the one that off switches naturally. On the surface not much, but the big difference is that naturally clam dog stays calm and evenhanded even the presence of game.

@JGood

1. True
2. True
3. True
4. True
5. True but keeping the original purpose of the dog is good. No need to turn a truck into a sportscar. Just a get a sportscar. Hence the tragic fate of the GSP.
6. No. Many accomplished cover dog trailers and breeders have usually less than 6 dogs. It will be an underestimation to say those guys have bad dogs have no idea what they are doing.
7. True
8. True
9. No. Style is subjective. There are people who think the Lab's working in the field is a better sight than a Pointer devouring the space. Those people are totally sincere with their feelings and not laying.
A good sturdy 9-10 o'clock tail is better than an ugly 12 o'clock sickle tail.
Creeping is great if a dog has a self-control and keeps the fleeing bird under the nose even by the time you get to him. The most of dog don't have self-control in the presence of game and flush the bird. See my post above.
10. Are there people like that?
11. wut??
12. No. Some versatile dog people do get delusional but generally speaking the V dogs are awesome, their performance is often above average in all categories, and they have their own distinct place in upland world.

 

[KurtR]

Of course both are factor, but genetics is the foundation. It dictates most of the outcomes and only thing we can do is either expand on it through training or conceal it through training.

When someone tell me his dog has off switch, my question is what is mostly achieved through training and the dog happens to be naturally calm.

One may ask, what is exactly the different between the dog that off switches via training and the one that off switches naturally. On the surface not much, but the big difference is that naturally clam dog stays calm and evenhanded even the presence of game.

@JGood

1. True
2. True
3. True
4. True
5. True but keeping the original purpose of the dog is good. No need to turn a truck into a sportscar. Just a get a sportscar. Hence the tragic fate of the GSP.
6. No. Many accomplished cover dog trailers and breeders have usually less than 6 dogs. It will be an underestimation to say those guys have bad dogs have no idea what they are doing.
7. True
8. True
9. No. Style is subjective. There are people who think the Lab's working in the field is a better sight than a Pointer devouring the space. Those people are totally sincere with their feelings and not laying.
A good sturdy 9-10 o'clock tail is better than an ugly 12 o'clock sickle tail.
Creeping is great if a dog has a self-control and keeps the fleeing bird under the nose even by the time you get to him. The most of dog don't have self-control in the presence of game and flush the bird. See my post above.
10. Are there people like that?
11. wut??
12. No. Some versatile dog people do get delusional but generally speaking the V dogs are awesome, their performance is often above average in all categories, and they have their own distinct place in upland world.

Creeping gets you sent home at the grand so its never good in my world plus dogs that creep dont mark as good as dogs who are steady.

I dont know any pros who have less than 6 dogs and most the top ams all have that many or more. You cant make a living on six dogs unless you get to charge some crazy amount.

Versatile dogs do lots of things good but they dont point like a pointer or retriever like a retriever

 

[el_jefe_pescado]

Versatile dogs do lots of things good but they dont point like a pointer or retriever like a retriever

Yeah that's fair