ResearchinStuff
WKR
Have you tried shooting it on a moist day yet? High humidity, foggy, snowing hard, or better yet rainy?
Patched roundball range day
- Thread starter 30338
- Start date
insanelupus
WKR
- Joined
- Sep 2, 2015
- Messages
- 657
Form,
I'm far from an expert, but was trained under the tuteludge of one who was. He built the .54 that I took this buck with several years ago at 75 yards. First time that rifle had been hunted in almost 30 years and my mentor died within a month of this photo being taken. Best present I could have given him. I've learned a little from others mistakes since then.
One word of caution, if you have to hammer that ram rod home with the tailgate, probably best to clean. Little good will come of doing so and often some form of damage can result. Sometimes, we have to accept and conform to the limitations of the tool we are using, or find a tool that better conforms to our standards.
Those pre lubed patches are convenient, true. As you have discovered, the tighter the patch/ball, typically the better the group. But powder fouling is a thing. Good Swiss powder (if it can be found, tough at the moment) is a gift and second to none. Running your patch material (100% cotton) through a hot wash cycle and drying is supposed to be beneficial, which means cutting (pre cut or at the muzzle) and lubing them . And experimenting with lube (hey, don't be weird here) is a good idea. Mink oil is often touted and that's been my go to for the rifle pictured. My mentor used a home brew of sheep tallow and beeswax, perhaps with a little linseed oil (memories fade). I asked once about bear grease and his experience indicated it is too thin. There is a balance in patch lube regarding thickness and viscocity I'm still learning.
I've purchased a .58 I need to repair a little and then get online next year. The rifles my mentor built are relegated to terrain I can navigate without falling these days, but the elk don't usually live there! Thus the purchased .58. I'll be playing with lube, ball size, and powder charges, provided I can find more 2F Swiss.
One thing friends have found helpful and I believe it was mentioned, a fiber wad over your powder charge before the PRB is seated. Research I've done indicates going up a caliber is helpful too (I'll be using .62 wads). Lowers extreme spread and has helped accuracy with several I know using conicals, but does the same for PRB.
My experience has all been with slow twist barrels for PRB and the .58 I have is basically a sporterized Remington 1863 Contract rifle that was never actually produced. An Antolio Zoli creation of the 70s. Complete with shallow rifling, 3 groove short barrel, and I've found multiple twists listed from moderate that should be PRB fine to slow and no good for conicals, which I doubt.
Rarely with a muzzlleloader will there be a generic secret sauce. More than modern rifles, each is a rule into its own and requires experimentation.
My mentor told me there have been and are many muzzleloaders capable of very good accuracy. He built many of them over his lifetime. But not every shooter is or has the patience to find it he told me. But the myth that PRB is not capable of small groups at 100 yards is just that, a myth. Not all muzzleloaders are capable of it, but he always reckoned there were fewer shooters capable of finding the necessary combo than there were muzzleloaders.
I'm far from an expert, but was trained under the tuteludge of one who was. He built the .54 that I took this buck with several years ago at 75 yards. First time that rifle had been hunted in almost 30 years and my mentor died within a month of this photo being taken. Best present I could have given him. I've learned a little from others mistakes since then.
One word of caution, if you have to hammer that ram rod home with the tailgate, probably best to clean. Little good will come of doing so and often some form of damage can result. Sometimes, we have to accept and conform to the limitations of the tool we are using, or find a tool that better conforms to our standards.
Those pre lubed patches are convenient, true. As you have discovered, the tighter the patch/ball, typically the better the group. But powder fouling is a thing. Good Swiss powder (if it can be found, tough at the moment) is a gift and second to none. Running your patch material (100% cotton) through a hot wash cycle and drying is supposed to be beneficial, which means cutting (pre cut or at the muzzle) and lubing them . And experimenting with lube (hey, don't be weird here) is a good idea. Mink oil is often touted and that's been my go to for the rifle pictured. My mentor used a home brew of sheep tallow and beeswax, perhaps with a little linseed oil (memories fade). I asked once about bear grease and his experience indicated it is too thin. There is a balance in patch lube regarding thickness and viscocity I'm still learning.
I've purchased a .58 I need to repair a little and then get online next year. The rifles my mentor built are relegated to terrain I can navigate without falling these days, but the elk don't usually live there! Thus the purchased .58. I'll be playing with lube, ball size, and powder charges, provided I can find more 2F Swiss.
One thing friends have found helpful and I believe it was mentioned, a fiber wad over your powder charge before the PRB is seated. Research I've done indicates going up a caliber is helpful too (I'll be using .62 wads). Lowers extreme spread and has helped accuracy with several I know using conicals, but does the same for PRB.
My experience has all been with slow twist barrels for PRB and the .58 I have is basically a sporterized Remington 1863 Contract rifle that was never actually produced. An Antolio Zoli creation of the 70s. Complete with shallow rifling, 3 groove short barrel, and I've found multiple twists listed from moderate that should be PRB fine to slow and no good for conicals, which I doubt.
Rarely with a muzzlleloader will there be a generic secret sauce. More than modern rifles, each is a rule into its own and requires experimentation.
My mentor told me there have been and are many muzzleloaders capable of very good accuracy. He built many of them over his lifetime. But not every shooter is or has the patience to find it he told me. But the myth that PRB is not capable of small groups at 100 yards is just that, a myth. Not all muzzleloaders are capable of it, but he always reckoned there were fewer shooters capable of finding the necessary combo than there were muzzleloaders.
Attachments
You need to get a new ram rod. At least the wood and pin the end on. I wouldn't trust any kind of glue. You can buy wood blanks from muzzleloader supply dealers. I make up a spare or two. A real range rod is a real plus.
Search - Track of the Wolf
Muzzle Loading & Black Powder Guns Kits, Parts, Accoutrements, Rendezvous Gear & Primitive Americana.
www.trackofthewolf.com
- Joined
- Oct 22, 2014
- Messages
- 14,836
Haha. They were ordered within 5min of it happening.
BBob
WKR
5lb of Swiss inbound. Guess I’m committed 
- Joined
- Oct 22, 2014
- Messages
- 14,836
5lb of Swiss inbound. Guess I’m committed
Man that’s a pretty good day of shooting…
Grin.
FrontierGander
WKR
With Swiss costing $60 a lb now, Im sure glad i make my own stuff lol.
ihookem
Lil-Rokslider
Where do you get your other two ingredients? I have the charcoal already that I made myself.
FrontierGander
WKR
Just off of Amazon. Bought them a handful of years ago.
ihookem
Lil-Rokslider
Do you prefer a brand of sulphur or potasium nitrate?
FrontierGander
WKR
No specific brand at all
HighUintas
WKR
- Joined
- Feb 2, 2020
- Messages
- 4,317
From my and common knowledge would say they're ok but the damaged/cut parts could potentially be detrimental to accuracy.
I have not seen a single person, anywhere, that has said it doesn't matter if patches are cut/damaged after shooting.
I haven't tested it in a controlled enough manner myself to say for sure, but I did have a gun that cut patches due to rough/raised burrs on the edges of the lands from crap machining. After fixing that, the accuracy seemed better. Prior to fixing it I'd get occasional fliers way out of the rest of the group. Like something obviously wrong ... Not cherry picking and 3rd groups.
I would like to see a controlled test though. I think to a degree it makes sense. If there is gas leakage around the patch or unequal friction between patch and bore on one side from damage, I would think that could cause big variation in pressure, etc.
From all I've been able to find, people seem to agree it doesn't matter as long as all sides are covered. I believe there have been tests to determine if it matters.... Even if the sprue being up/down/off center matters, and those said it doesn't. But I can't remember who tested this and don't have a link.
A few things:
Tight spot in breech after shooting- swiss has the potential to cause a worse fouling ring in the bottom, for whatever reason. I usually use schuetzen which is dirty as all hell in my gun (but does not make a hard ring) and tried swiss this year. After a couple shots, yes there's a crazy hard ring in the bottom and all other who've experienced this agree that when that hard ring forms your accuracy goes to crap... I think it probably changes pressure if it doesn't damage the patch. I have experienced the issue. I do not know how to prevent it other than swabbing it out.
Shots being lower on clean bore - yes a clean bore produces lower MV and I guess lower pressure. I have noticed this with mine with certain loads. With a super tight combo in my two guns it seems to not make as much difference between clean/fouled bore. This is where having a tight enough patch/ball combo and a good lube helps. If it's tight enough, and the patch is moist enough, it will basically wipe the bore each time you load and give the same bore condition each time. I do this because taking the time to swab drives me nuts.
Patches- the prelubed are handy, but using a super tight weave and very strong material supposedly works best for accuracy. There are none of this quality that are prelubed that I know of. Using tighter weave that is stronger material means no gas blow by, which is supposedly beneficial to accuracy. Idaholewis has shown it a couple times in his videos. He'll use precut patches that are thin, but he will double patch... Put a patch over the powder below the patched ball which protects the integrity of the patch on the ball. I haven't tested this myself because I went straight to loading the tightest load I could from the get go. However, I have seen accuracy degrade with damage patches or completely blown patches.
Look into minute men patching. Tightest and toughest stuff I've found. Wash regular cycle, rinse twice, dry medium. Cut strips and then cut at the muzzle using spit for lube to make it easy. https://www.theminute-menpatches.com/ try the 0.018 and 0.020.
Could also find some tight weave duck canvas that measures 0.018-0.020 with calipers when squeezed really hard with one hand. Same thing. Wash and dry.
Here's a large round count group at 100 with a 54 Hawken . 90gr 2f swiss. Wind was gusting so I was trying to hold for that. Without the wind, I can typically put them all in the black. My flintlock is a different story. As soon as I can see out of my right eye again I'll get out and shoot some more large count groups.
- Joined
- Oct 22, 2014
- Messages
- 14,836
The issue near the breech is pretty severe pitting- we used a bore scope and it is obvious. @longrangelead is going to see if he can lap it out.
As for Swiss, I have shot a bit with another MZ and have seen no real issue when not swabbing with it.
That is what I understand and what so far shows in previous shooting with other MZ’s. With this CVA is was just the pitting.
I’m going to test prelubed versus not heavily.
I will be trying the over powder wad/patch too.
Already have some. Thank you.
I’m going to try a bunch of different patches, including leather and paper cartridges.
I don’t think keeping 10 round groups inside the black of a B8 bull at 100y will prove to be too much for PRB’s and a flintlock.
Appreciate the info man.
Grabbed a .45 flinter out of the safe yesterday. Haven't shot this one much and this is the first time putting it on paper. Here were the first 10 at 100yd off of a rest. Wind was 15mph gusting to 25mph. I held center on every shot and the horizontal stringing reflects it (8" horizontal vs 3" vertical spread). Not stoked with this group but it is a start.
Rifle has 36" douglas xx .45 barrel. Load was as follows:
.445" hand cast ball
.018" spit lubed pillow ticking patch cut at muzzle
70gr 3f goex (2024 production i.e. "New"/ Post Estes Energetics buyout)
Swiss 0b in the pan
No swabbing/cleaning
Going to be shooting this rifle some more in the near future to see what it will do with different loads in calmer conditions. Plan to change the sights soon as well as these are not comfortable for my eyes especially when dim/overcast.
Rifle has 36" douglas xx .45 barrel. Load was as follows:
.445" hand cast ball
.018" spit lubed pillow ticking patch cut at muzzle
70gr 3f goex (2024 production i.e. "New"/ Post Estes Energetics buyout)
Swiss 0b in the pan
No swabbing/cleaning
Going to be shooting this rifle some more in the near future to see what it will do with different loads in calmer conditions. Plan to change the sights soon as well as these are not comfortable for my eyes especially when dim/overcast.
HighUintas
WKR
- Joined
- Feb 2, 2020
- Messages
- 4,317
Awesome. Glad you found the problem.
I'd like to get a 40 or 45 flintlock to try to conquer the flinch. The pan sound and flash and heavy recoil of my 58 makes me flinch quite badly. Best I've done is about 4" at 100 for 10 shots but my flinching makes that not repeatable.
HighUintas
WKR
- Joined
- Feb 2, 2020
- Messages
- 4,317
I'd be super happy with that with my flintlock. Dang flinching....
Glad to see theres another person here interested in showing what can be done with a flintlock on demand.
If you guys have any suggestions for getting rid of a flinch from the pan sound and flash, I'm all ears. I think it is more that than the recoil, but the recoil definitely doesn't help.
HighUintas
WKR
- Joined
- Feb 2, 2020
- Messages
- 4,317
This thread has me thinking I might need to get out and see what I can do shooting lefty since it could be months before I can shoot right again.
- Joined
- Oct 22, 2014
- Messages
- 14,836
Ahhh. Yeah, that’s rough. I’m trying to find the right 36cal a or 40cal. I think I want an Edward Marshall in 40cal, but that seems hard to get in kit form.
- Joined
- Oct 22, 2014
- Messages
- 14,836
I think (we’ll see) I’ll figure the flinch thing out pretty quickly. When the rifle comes in I’ll take some video and see what happens. I’ve taken videos with the cap locks, and even with muskrat caps throwing nonsense out- no flinch.
Similar threads
Featured Video
Latest Articles
- The Next Level in Optics with Ryan Holm of Leica
- Teratorn Backpack Review
- Argali Serac MagnaCut Knife Review
- James Yates: Leveraging Data for Archery Excellence
- How Old Was He Really? Big Buck Hunters Talk Age vs. Score
- Banning Hunting Technology in Idaho?
- Best Gear of the year Rokslide staff edition 2025 Article
- Hunting Gear: Insights from Western Hunting Expo
- Black Diamond Alpine Start Insulated Hoody Review
- Tenacity Firearms with Andrew Whitney