9MM ammo for bears defense?

[Lowg08]

I would choose a solid cast projectile. The biggest thing for me is to be a proficient shooter. A well placed shot with bad ammo will be better than a horribly placed shot with far superior ammo

 

[Yukon Cornelius]

I would choose a solid cast projectile. The biggest thing for me is to be a proficient shooter. A well placed shot with bad ammo will be better than a horribly placed shot with far superior ammo

Not sure. Brown bears you need penetration. Ammo is extremely important here. That solid cast ammo gets penetration and I personally know someone that dumped a full mag of jhp 10mm into a brown bear. It lived, but he was able to turn the bear away from him.

 

[Lowg08]

I agree ammo is important but a cast bullet to the leg in my opinion would not do as well as a cast bullet to the head

 

[Yukon Cornelius]

I agree ammo is important but a cast bullet to the leg in my opinion would not do as well as a cast bullet to the head

But then they are both cast bullets. Jhp to the head? Vs hard cast to the leg?

Lol. I’d hate to be in either situation.

 

[Lowg08]

Yea I’m not necessarily wanting to try my luck either.

 

[dla]

I have both a Glock 19 and 20.I practice with both but shoot the 19 much better.Fortunately haven't had to use either.
So much info out there about ammo I took the recommendations that sounded valid and did my own tests on thick cedar creosoted posts(admittedly not scientific).Then I decided on what I will use.(FWIW)
For the 20:a clip staggered with Underwood 200 gr Hard cast(1250fps) and Underwood 140 gr Extreme Penetrators(1500fps)
If out of the Penetrators would substitute 150 gr Extreme Hunters(1425fps)

For the 19:115 gr Extreme Penetrators(1250fps)

I think you would be much better off with hardcast.
Here is some info from a fellow who tested "extreme penetrators": https://general-cartridge.com/category/field-loads/

 

[SoDaky]

dla yes I've seen that.There are a number of 'tests'going all over on them,that's why I did my own.I came to my own conclusions based on my tests.Go with what works for you for sure.

 

[jmazz]

Has anyone had any issues with the Buffalo Bore 9mm+P Outdoorsman?

I tried it in a Glock 19, Glock 23 with 9mm Conversion Barrel, and S&W M&P 9mm. I couldn't get the Buffalo Bore to chamber correctly in the Glock 23/9mm and S&W. It chambers perfectly fine in my Glock 19.

I guess the lesson here that relates to the thread is to test out the ammunition with your specific pistol before you carry it into bear country.

 

[elkeaterco]

Ryan, these would be my top picks. I'm going to run them in my G43 while guiding in Alaska. After watching some impressive youtube videos out of a 9mm. I feel confident sleeping in the bush with this combo.

Lehigh defense extreme penetrator
Lehigh extreme defense bullets
G9 Woodsman
G9 EHP

Jake
@elkhunter34

 

[thinhorn_AK]

Ryan, these would be my top picks. I'm going to run them in my G43 while guiding in Alaska. After watching some impressive youtube videos out of a 9mm. I feel confident sleeping in the bush with this combo.

Lehigh defense extreme penetrator
Lehigh extreme defense bullets
G9 Woodsman
G9 EHP

Jake
@elkhunter34

I got my wife a glock 43 and use the leghigh defense penetrators, I feel comfortable with her carrying that.

 

[MrTim]

In addition to bear spray, I carry a G19 in griz country. That’s the only pistol I have. I load it with 147 grain fmj. These feed and shoot well. Never had to use it against a bear.
For what it’s worth, it did kill a bovine cow that had to be put down. 1st one to the skull put her out of commission, the 2nd killed her.

 

[MuleDeerMike]

Anyone know how the 9mm Buffalo Bore +P Outdoorsman round directly compares to the Buffalo Bore +P+ Penetrator? For bears and cats.

 

[Beendare]

Has anyone had any issues with the Buffalo Bore 9mm+P Outdoorsman?

I tried it in a Glock 19, Glock 23 with 9mm Conversion Barrel, and S&W M&P 9mm. I couldn't get the Buffalo Bore to chamber correctly in the Glock 23/9mm and S&W. It chambers perfectly fine in my Glock 19.

I guess the lesson here that relates to the thread is to test out the ammunition with your specific pistol before you carry it into bear country.

Well of course you have to test it if you are betting your life on it- practice too. I've run a couple hundred rounds of the BB +P ammo in my G17 and G19 stock barrels- no problems. I haven't tested it like my primary G20- that I've run over 500rds of Underwood 200gr hardcast in without one failure [stock barrel, no leading issues if you clean it regularly]

I can see why many don't test to this^ extent...the dang ammo costs you as much as the pistol!

I also have a KKM conversion barrel in my G23 and wouldn't use that as my defensive pistol. The KKM barrel has a tighter chamber by a couple thousandths- probably why you are having feeding issues.
I have only had a couple FTF's in thousands of rounds through my G23/9mm KKM and those FTF's could be due to new shooters limp wristing it.

______

 

[Ryan Avery]

If you wanna see how bad you can piss off a grizzly bear that’s already charging to kill you......go ahead and shoot it with a 9mm...........maybe your partner will hear you die screaming and can shoot it with his 10mm....
I got a life lesson with a huge black sow and a 40cal last fall.....10mm or larger for me from here on out.
If your gonna go....go big..

Love the matter of fact...opinion on grizz!

From all my research a 10mm ain’t doing much over a 9mm with good bullets.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[MtnOyster]

Love the matter of fact...opinion on grizz!

From all my research a 10mm ain’t doing much over a 9mm with good bullets.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

good luck with any caliber you choose, hopefully you’ll never have to use it...

 

[Wolvie604]

For what it’s worth-

I once defence shot a black with a 147 grain 9 organ region when it got up after being hit by a truck quicker then expected. It didn’t like it. Bear went to tree and earned a 308 headshot.

I would be shocked to see the same reaction from a G bear though.

 

[SlickTrick123]

I would suggest loads with the Lehigh defense extreme penetrator or extreme defense bullets. They give a wound cavity similar to a hp, but penetrate much better.

This

 

[jakelogsdon]

Just make the last one a HP for yourself.

The Story of the Alaska Man Who Killed a Charging Brown Bear with a 9mm Pistol

It's a miracle this Alaskan fishing guide lived to tell the tale.

www.wideopenspaces.com

 

[dla]

Testing says otherwise. Plain 147gr hardcast is far better. See links in earlier posts.

Quote Reply
Report •••
First Prev5 of 5

 

[dla]

Ryan, these would be my top picks. I'm going to run them in my G43 while guiding in Alaska. After watching some impressive youtube videos out of a 9mm. I feel confident sleeping in the bush with this combo.

Lehigh defense extreme penetrator
Lehigh extreme defense bullets
G9 Woodsman
G9 EHP

Jake
@elkhunter34

Testing says otherwise. Plain 147gr hardcast is far better. See links in earlier posts.