Bummer the Leupold's have not served as well for you.
You mention up front there were "more than a few accidental falls" and rough handling.
If weight needs to be in there against human error and accidents, I'll take the chance that I can overcome most of it versus rely on the scope to handle it.
My experience is 30 years in the backcountry and can say they've endured everything I've put their way. I could not hold something accountable for failing to perform (in the moment or later on) after the treatment that has been openly shared. I am sure a Meopta that hadn't been used like that has held up well, unless it has had the same life as the Leupold and it is being said the Meopta handled the same "more than a few accidental falls" and rough handling as the Leupold.
Have been using Leupold's for 30 years on a 300 Winchester Magnum, a 35 Whelen AI, .280 Remington and haven't had an issue.
300 Winchester Magnum round count is over 1,000 on a 3-9 Vari-X IIc put on in 1996, 35 Whelen well over 600 with the 3-9 VX-2 put on in 2001, another 75 rounds with the new VX3HD 3.5-10 put on this year and a 280 Remington with a 3-9 Leupold compact. Always held zero and the clicks on the VX3HD worked just like they should using a 100 yd zero and reaching out past 200 yards. At the end of each day I would click it back to the hundred yard zero. Then click up to what I needed for the next shot at hand in the following days.
Thanks for willingness to share your experience on it, and felt it was good with respect to the discussion to give a bit more detail on my experience to the positive.