Round in the Chamber

[Dave0317]

So you’re arguing that carrying a loaded rifle is just as safe as an unloaded one? That’s your argument?

That’s not even close to what he said, lol.

He just said it’s not necessarily un-safe to carry a loaded rifle. Not that it’s safer than an unloaded, not that accidents are impossible. Just that it’s not unsafe to carry a loaded gun (presumably given the four safety rules are adhered to as close as possible).

 

[Rich M]

I have bird hunted probably 200 separate occasions with 100’s of hunters. No exaggeration.

I have never once seen someone load their gun when dog on point.

Not saying someone somewhere doesn’t do this. But that’s not in the same stratosphere with “a lot of bird hunters.”

That’s the way we did it.

It used to be more popular i guess. I must be getting old.

Same way some guys (purists) wouldn’t shoot anything the dogs havent pointed. Dont tell me folks dont do that anymore either.

 

[Dave_S]

That’s not even close to what he said, lol.

He just said it’s not necessarily un-safe to carry a loaded rifle. Not that it’s safer than an unloaded, not that accidents are impossible. Just that it’s not unsafe to carry a loaded gun (presumably given the four safety rules are adhered to as close as possible).

Idk, I've been perusing the "stuff overheard in local gun stores" thread, and now I'm thinking nobody should load guns. Ever. lol

 

[Dave_S]

So you’re arguing that carrying a loaded rifle is just as safe as an unloaded one? That’s your argument?

I feel like my position was pretty clearly stated. We don't agree. That's ok.

 

[Rich M]

That’s not even close to what he said, lol.

He just said it’s not necessarily un-safe to carry a loaded rifle. Not that it’s safer than an unloaded, not that accidents are impossible. Just that it’s not unsafe to carry a loaded gun (presumably given the four safety rules are adhered to as close as possible).

Exactly. Noone would ever get shot if folks would just live by safe gun handling.

I am not gonna point a gun at you loaded or unloaded. Treat every gun as if it is loaded….

 

[AG8]

This is turning into a spoons made me fat argument. An inanimate object is neither safe nor unsafe. Only people are. And there are plenty out there on both ends. If you are not comfortable with it, then don’t do it. You are certainly not wrong. With regard to doing it one way alone, but acting differently with others or kids around, I get the sentiment. But to me, I trust myself with my own life. I trust myself with my kids’ lives (if I didn’t, I would never put them in the car…). In that case, I certainly wouldn’t be taking them along in the first place. With an empty rifle or a slingshot.

 

[M0617]

Definitely an “it depends” for me. Moving to and from the are where I expect to encounter game - no. Once I anticipate game in the immediate area - yes.

 

[TaperPin]

How does the entire US military function? There are units that will discipline you for having an empty chamber even on post.

How many military bases outside of combat zones have loaded rifles just walking around if they aren’t at the range. None.

 

[TaperPin]

Scissors are not inherently dangerous, but we expect some common sense before junior graduates to sharp pointy ones, and even the best Olympic runner shouldn’t run with them despite how much experience running they have.

 

[HandgunHTR]

I judge people based off this question. If you chamber a round and walk around you’re a fuggin idiot. There is no exception.

Don’t worry, we are judging you back.

 

[Dave0317]

How many military bases outside of combat zones have loaded rifles just walking around if they aren’t at the range. None.

I would bet none. I never said anything about in/out of a combat zone.

In fact, the vast majority even in combat zones don’t allow it. You load up when you leave the gates.
But small posts in dangerous areas, staffed by well trained units, sometimes do.

 

[Jethro]

Don’t worry, we are judging you back.

I’m not judging him. @FAAFO knows how to carry stuff. Couple months ago he taught us proper way to carry an inreach. Now a firearm. I’m no idiot. Anxiously awaiting next lesson.

 

[FAAFO]

How does the entire US military function? There are units that will discipline you for having an empty chamber even on post. Good thing we have all the idiot cops carrying loaded guns into schools to stop active shooters. Good thing we have such idiot soldiers that they are willing to walk around with loaded guns and hunt down threats to our nation.

I don’t think hunters need to assume they should always have a loaded chamber, but it’s pretty ignorant to say someone else is a “fugging idiot” when they have a certain amount of training and experience that allows them to make an informed decision on when they can safely do so, and when they do or do not need that level of readiness.

youre comparing military to hunters in the woods. Seriously?

That deer trying to shoot back at ya?

 

[FAAFO]

I’m not judging him. @FAAFO knows how to carry stuff. Couple months ago he taught us proper way to carry an inreach. Now a firearm. I’m no idiot. Anxiously awaiting next lesson.

I’m still laughing about that thread. Guys carrying their Inreach outside their pack because just in case of an emergency? They can’t reach in their pack? Why isn’t their first aid kit strapped to the outside of their pack? You know, just in case.

I think guys want to pretend they are GI joe. Walk around with a round in the chamber, all that shit strapped to the outside of their pack.

 

[RS3579]

I judge people based off this question. If you chamber a round and walk around you’re a fuggin idiot. There is no exception.

Does this apply to concealed carry?

 

[RS3579]

I carry “one in the chamber” every time I leave the vehicle and am lawfully allowed to. Also a maximum in the magazine. Ya just never know when it’s needed.

 

[FAAFO]

Does this apply to concealed carry?

Yes