Not the regular what cartridge poll.

[NevadaMike]

I have three very reliable and accurate rifles I am considering for my upcoming elk hunt. I have been on several elk hunts but so far I am just a pack mule and have not had the opportunity to punch my own tag. I have only seen one elk take a hit and it took two. I am headed out on an Idaho elk hunt next month and I really do not think I would shoot over 500 in perfect conditions. My hunting experience is very limited and I have only taken 4 small Alaska bucks all under 100 yards. I do a reasonable amount of shooting but my big game experience is ZERO! My intention has always been to take the 7 PRC but with all the discussions here I am conflicted. Thoughts?

1. Seekins Element in 7PRC suppressed. For this rifle I am running Berger 180 VLD-H and it shoots them extremely well. I took it to a long range class and verified everything out to 1000 and won the little milk jug challenge at the end of the weekend. I can generally stay in the glass when I have good form but that is not always possible.

2. Fierce 6.5 creedmoor. This rifle loves 143 ELD-X. I took this rifle to a different long range school and I am very confident with it as well. Staying in the glass is pretty easy.

3. Seekins PH-2 NRL-H in 6 Creedmoor. This one likes Berger 105 VLD-H and is a legit tack driver. I still do not think I would take shot over 500. This one got me to second overall in a hunter competition. Staying in the glass is almost a given unless there is some strange contorted position.

 

[Caseknife]

Any one of them will work. I'd say do what I do and take the rifle that hasn't killed anything yet, but maybe not in your case being new at this passion.

 

[Elbow]

The way you describe them, #3 sounds like the one you're most confident with. If that's the case, why risk one of the others?

 

[ljalberta]

All will kill an elk. I voted 6CM based on the fact it is the easiest to spot impacts with and make adjustments on any follow up shot.

 

[Ynothunt41]

The 143ELD-X does a great job on Elk. I love that bullet. Take the lungs out.

 

[Indian Summer]

I’d go with that 180 grain out of your first choice.

 

[N2TRKYS]

The lightest one. You’re gonna tote it way more than you’re gonna shoot it.

 

[Seak_angler]

All Great combos. All of them will kill! Take the one you shoot the most confident. & Send it !

 

[NevadaMike]

The lightest one. You’re gonna tote it way more than you’re gonna shoot it.

That is the 7 PRC. So far its leading the poll too.

 

[NevadaMike]

The 143ELD-X does a great job on Elk. I love that bullet. Take the lungs out.

That is the one I used on the little Alaska blacktail. The lungs and heart were mush every time.

 

[peaches]

Bull or cow? Bull, take the 7. Cow any of the 3.

Shooting live animals in the wild, field positions, tired, heart pumping etc ain't popping water jugs at the range. Get as close as you can. Good luck

 

[NevadaMike]

Bull or cow? Bull, take the 7. Cow any of the 3.

Shooting live animals in the wild, field positions, tired, heart pumping etc ain't popping water jugs at the range. Get as close as you can. Good luck

My tag is for a bull and the poll seems to match my gut for the 7. I dumped a wolf with it last year when I was elk hunting. I was prone on a lumpy rock outcrop but I managed to get set up okay and when he walked into the last window I had for him I took the shot. I did lose my sight picture very briefly but I was back on him when he tumbled down hill. The 7 is also my lightest rifle.

 

[peaches]

Sounds like you already made your choice but just want some reassurance. Again, good luck.

 

[lyle_destroys]

How is this not like every other cartridge poll?

 

[5811]

How is this not like every other cartridge poll?

He didn't mention scope brands. Usually it's a choice with different leupold, zeiss, vortex scopes on the rifles in question and the responses turn into a brand fanboy dance-off.

 

[NevadaMike]

How is this not like every other cartridge poll?

These are the three platforms I have.

 

[NevadaMike]

Sounds like you already made your choice but just want some reassurance. Again, good luck.

Thanks. I was leaning 7 PRC but with all the small caliber discussions I was second guessing myself. This group has so much more experience than I do I figured it could only help.

 

[Tbone26]

I'm in a similar situation although I shoot and am more confident with my Creedmoor's than my 7 PRC. I am leaning towards my 6.5 Creedmoor with 140 eldm for a bull hunt this October. I have still not made my mind up.. I would keep my shots under 500 to keep my impact velocity above 2,000 fps for peace of mind. What do you guys think?

 

[NevadaMike]

I'm in a similar situation although I shoot and am more confident with my Creedmoor's than my 7 PRC. I am leaning towards my 6.5 Creedmoor with 140 eldm for a bull hunt this October. I have still not made my mind up.. I would keep my shots under 500 to keep my impact velocity above 2,000 fps for peace of mind. What do you guys think?

As you can tell from my original post I am no expert. The poll results like the 7 PRC at least for me. I would take them both out to a range where you can shoot a few boxes out of each rifle and then make your decision. Try seeing how long it takes to deliver a follow up shot with each. I have not done it personally but the 6.5 should get the job done. If you are more confident with it after a little practice I see no reason not to use it.

 

[sndmn11]

I My hunting experience is very limited and I have only taken 4 small Alaska bucks all under 100 yards. I do a reasonable amount of shooting but my big game experience is ZERO!

...

3. Seekins PH-2 NRL-H in 6 Creedmoor. ...
. I still do not think I would take shot over 500.