huntnful
WKR
- Joined
- Oct 10, 2020
Isn’t that the truth hahaha. I’ve been on both ends lol.The guys who clean a lot can mess things up just as much as the guys who clean too little. Gotta be smart.
Isn’t that the truth hahaha. I’ve been on both ends lol.The guys who clean a lot can mess things up just as much as the guys who clean too little. Gotta be smart.
Who says never clean? I don’t ever remember that. I think you are over simplifying it way too far.
My question for the “ no clean “ guys is this. If you NEVER clean, or clean “ when the rifle tells you”, do you end up having to deal with the dreaded CARBON RING? I wonder if the majority of those who report the nightmares related to the carbon ring, and those having to use stuff only slightly less dramatic than dynamite to get it out, are most often those who rarely if ever clean their barrels or those who wait until “ the rifle tells them “.Who says never clean? I don’t ever remember that. I think you are over simplifying it way too far.
The “no clean” guys say they never clean until accuracy degrades. Which is what you said.
I have been under a rock, apparently. I don’t remember any specific bore cleaning threads cause it’s not that overall important in the grand scheme of things. Could be cause I am getting old…You been under a rock? Ryan Avery and Form for 2 that are pretty influential around here that say they never clean bores.
@justin davis
To be fair you groups “opened up” to what .5-.6?
That’s better than most fells shoot to begin with.
And if you go with @Formidilosus match he has show with hit rate prob it doesn’t matter as long as you stay under 1.5 cone of accuracy.
So yeah doesn’t matter. Really
To the “frequent” cleaner category I’d add those who like reliability. Since I was 20ish I’ve never trouble shot a rifle, or just worked up a load and had to wonder if the barrel is too dirty. I’ve never had to wonder if a load is over pressure because of a carbon ring, or been hunting and had to wonder if today was the day a dirty barrel will cause a problem.“Frequent” cleaners are falling into the category where they care about ultimate precision, cartridge choices that have problems with carbon rings, and some OCD maybe cause they like stuff clean.
the guys that say you don’t need to clean ever…I’m not sure I buy it. I want to get on board but I’ve seen accuracy degrade and cleaning tighten it up. Just recently my 6.5 prc started shooting bigger groups. I was trying to figure out what the deal was. It has it had about 180 shots thru it since last cleaning. It Was shooting weird.
I cleaned barrel and the group tighten right up
Very well said. That exactly how I view it as well.I have been under a rock, apparently. I don’t remember any specific bore cleaning threads cause it’s not that overall important in the grand scheme of things. Could be cause I am getting old…
I was wrong.
I largely agree, if the rifle hits what you want, who cares about cleaning. It’s not a magical mystical thing for the vast majority, but the details get lost on people. Or, at least they don’t know who to believe or why.
Those that “never” clean, based on what people are saying, they “never” get beyond their acceptable level of precision. That’s ok and reasonable. It saves barrels from the error of over cleaning too much.
Many barrels don’t need much cleaning to stay precise enough for the “cone of accuracy” for increased tolerance towards group size. Many chambers and cartridges will never have a problem with the carbon ring.
Never cleaners are falling into a subset that don’t need it because of rifle/chamber/cartridge choices. Also some laziness cause they see it doesn’t matter.
There are factors and preferences that put them in that camp. The other side is the “must clean” camp.
Like many things, change the criteria and circumstances and change the answer.
The answer I give is nearly always, it depends… there is rarely a “correct” answer. Carbon rings are real, so I would assume the never cleaners are making choices that avoid it.
“Frequent” cleaners are falling into the category where they care about ultimate precision, cartridge choices that have problems with carbon rings, and some OCD maybe cause they like stuff clean.
For me, I don’t chase super small groups so I don’t freak out about cleaning. I am good with a real 1 moa on my long range guns and some rifles only need to meet a 3 moa group for its purpose.
I have nice barrels that haven’t been cleaned in over 1000 rounds. Is that “never cleaning” if I happen to burn the barrel maintaining my level of accuracy, si guess for that barrel am I a never cleaner?
If a shooter is happy with 1.5 moa cone of accuracy, that’s cool. And, many barrels wouldn’t need it.
To Forms point about group size and field precision, most don’t need to clean to maintain killing precision to the ranges that the vast majority shoot. Given that, I think some barrels get cleaned based off of 3 shot groups on a shooters bad range day that don’t actually represent a decline in accuracy.
Another example of a possibly confounding factor about cleaning is whether to clean between switching between monos and jacketed bullets. It has nothing to do with “clean” but rather whatever weird thing happens to the bore, if it actually happens…
Three-shot groups don't tell you much.
I haven't cleaned a rifle bore in at least ten years.
But does that increased accuracy do anything for you besides make you feel good?Yea I know 3 shots don’t mean squat. But I just used those pics as a reference to what I saw. There was a clear increase in accuracy after cleaning
The honest answer for me is no. I just like it haha. My guns do seem to shoot a LITTLE better on a clean bore.But does that increased accuracy do anything for you besides make you feel good?