Is Creatine worth the weight gain?

I’m curious to read the advice from those with much more Creatine experience than I have.

I’ve been taking a scoop of wilderness Athlete brand Creatine HMB after workouts, which is what they recommend. However, a few weeks ago I started taking it daily before bed due to learning more about its cognitive benefits. They recommend 5mg, but I’ve been heaping the scoop so probably getting 7.5-8mg each night. Problem is, it’s very expensive ($42 for a 30 5mg serving tub) so I’m looking at alternatives in order to up my dose and reduce cost while also maintains full benefits.

Would those with more experience than me (most of you) recommend sticking with a brand that includes HMB or not worry so much about whether it’s included or not. I’m going to look at what Costco has and also check out the brands recommended by some of you. Going forward, I’m shooting fot 10-15 grams a day, split between morning and evening. Am I overthinking this?
 
I buy the Fitness Labs German Creatine. It is Creapure and container is 500 grams, (100 5 gram servings).
Walmart, Amazon, etc has it for about $45. It is in a green and black container.
I bought my last container from PipingRockHealthProducts on Ebay for $37.99, free shipping but they charge tax- total was $43

Avoid any that does not say Creapure. All other Creatine is made in China, Creapure is made in Germany.
Wow, that def is cheaper than TheFeed's Creapure. Thanks for sharing. One ding is that they don't do NSF certification, but it's probably what they say it is.
 
I’m curious to read the advice from those with much more Creatine experience than I have.

I’ve been taking a scoop of wilderness Athlete brand Creatine HMB after workouts, which is what they recommend. However, a few weeks ago I started taking it daily before bed due to learning more about its cognitive benefits. They recommend 5mg, but I’ve been heaping the scoop so probably getting 7.5-8mg each night. Problem is, it’s very expensive ($42 for a 30 5mg serving tub) so I’m looking at alternatives in order to up my dose and reduce cost while also maintains full benefits.

Would those with more experience than me (most of you) recommend sticking with a brand that includes HMB or not worry so much about whether it’s included or not. I’m going to look at what Costco has and also check out the brands recommended by some of you. Going forward, I’m shooting fot 10-15 grams a day, split between morning and evening. Am I overthinking this?
The only people I've seen recommending Creatine HMB are supplement companies that sell Creatine HMB. Any people I've trusted in the strength/fitness space (Layne Norton, Eric Helms, Mike Israetel, etc) just recommend using regular ol' creatine monohydrate.

As for dosing, if you're using cheaper creatine monohydrate, it doesn't cost much to try a higher dose for a while and see how you feel. If you want to split up the dose to avoid gut problems, that's great. I just like to take it once in the day so I take 1-2 scoops (5-10g).
 
I’m curious to read the advice from those with much more Creatine experience than I have.

I’ve been taking a scoop of wilderness Athlete brand Creatine HMB after workouts, which is what they recommend. However, a few weeks ago I started taking it daily before bed due to learning more about its cognitive benefits. They recommend 5mg, but I’ve been heaping the scoop so probably getting 7.5-8mg each night. Problem is, it’s very expensive ($42 for a 30 5mg serving tub) so I’m looking at alternatives in order to up my dose and reduce cost while also maintains full benefits.

Would those with more experience than me (most of you) recommend sticking with a brand that includes HMB or not worry so much about whether it’s included or not. I’m going to look at what Costco has and also check out the brands recommended by some of you. Going forward, I’m shooting fot 10-15 grams a day, split between morning and evening. Am I overthinking this?
Unfortunately, companies out there prey on the consumer knowing they will buy based on the activity. In this case supplement companies targeting hunters. There are many options out there, for creatine Monohydrate, that are much better than MTN Ops or Wilderness Athlete. You can get Optimum Nutrition Creatine at sams club for $20 for a 135 serving container.

I know some may or may not like ON brand supplements. However it is just an example.
 
Any of the Creapure in gummies that someone would recommend?
The only one I've used is Legion Athletics creatine gummies. They don't use Creapure, but they are third party tested and are shown to have the amount of creatine that they claim. They are significantly more expensive per serving than just getting regular creatine powder though.

I would also be careful of other creatine gummies. I've seen videos where they check a lot of different supplement companies gummies and find they don't have the claimed amount in each if any at all.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CMF
In addition to benefits already mentioned, there is starting to be more and more conversation about benefits of creatine for endurance athletes.

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10132248/
Here is the Ai summarized version of the article:

Here's a clear, concise summary of the narrative review on **creatine supplementation and endurance performance**:

### Overall Takeaway
Creatine is a well-established ergogenic aid for strength, power, and short high-intensity efforts, but its effects on endurance exercise (activities >~3 minutes involving large muscle groups in a cyclical manner) are more nuanced. While it can increase body mass (potentially detrimental in weight-bearing sports like running), it offers several mechanisms that may improve performance—especially in races with repeated high-intensity surges, breakaways, or strong finishing sprints. Benefits are more consistent in non-weight-bearing or mixed-intensity endurance sports (e.g., cycling, rowing, kayaking, mountain biking, triathlon, cross-country skiing) than in steady-state efforts.

### Key Potential Mechanisms
- **Elevated muscle phosphocreatine (PCr) and total creatine**: Allows faster ATP resynthesis, greater anaerobic capacity, and better hydrogen ion buffering during intense efforts.
- **Enhanced glycogen storage**: When taken with carbohydrates, creatine increases muscle glycogen content and resynthesis, providing more fuel for high-intensity aerobic work.
- **Improved buffering and reduced reliance on glycolysis**: Lowers lactate accumulation and supports repeated high-intensity bouts.
- **Better neuromuscular efficiency**: May reduce motor unit recruitment for a given intensity, delay neuromuscular fatigue, and improve calcium handling for better force production.
- **Mitochondrial and recovery benefits**: Potential to support mitochondrial function/biogenesis, reduce oxidative stress and inflammation (e.g., lower TNF-alpha, PGE2, creatine kinase), and aid post-exercise recovery.
- **Drawback**: Short-term loading increases body water and body mass (~0.9–2 kg), which may impair weight-bearing endurance performance.

### Effects on Endurance Performance
- **Time to Exhaustion (TTE) and high-intensity work**: Mostly positive. Creatine consistently improves TTE or total work in short-to-moderate high-intensity efforts (~3–6+ min) and protocols with repeated surges or intervals. Benefits are linked to increased anaerobic work capacity (W') and power output during intense bursts.
- **Time Trial (TT) Performance**: Mixed results. No consistent improvement in steady-state or long continuous TTs (e.g., 6-km run or 20–120 km cycling). However, creatine often enhances **end spurts** and **final sprints** (e.g., last 50 m in swimming, closing sprints in cycling, final splits in rowing), which are frequently race-defining.
- **Intermittent/Surge-Based Endurance**: Promising for sports involving frequent intensity changes (e.g., mountain biking, road cycling pack racing, triathlon). Creatine improves repeated high-intensity efforts without impairing aerobic work.
- **Specific Examples from Studies**:
- Improved final sprint in 400-m swim and 1000-m rowing.
- Better power in closing sprints during 120-km cycling TT (with carbs).
- Enhanced interval work and TTE in triathletes.
- Increased work capacity above critical power in some studies.

Body mass gain appears more problematic in running than in cycling or rowing.

### Practical Recommendations from the Review
- **Dosing**:
- Standard loading: 20 g/day (or 0.3 g/kg/day) split into 4 doses for 5–7 days → maintenance 3–5 g/day.
- For weight-bearing athletes (to minimize water retention): Skip loading and use 3–5 g/day for ~4 weeks.
- Best results when co-ingested with carbohydrates (enhances creatine and glycogen uptake).
- Creatine monohydrate is the most researched and effective form.
- Useful during high-intensity interval training blocks.
- Individual response varies (based on baseline creatine levels, muscle fiber type, genetics, diet). “Non-responders” exist, especially in those with high baseline stores (e.g., some females).
- Practice with it in training/off-season before competition.
- Beneficial for both recreational and elite athletes in surge-heavy or sprint-finish sports.

### Limitations & Future Directions
- Limited studies on real competitive endurance events.
- Mixed results partly due to differences in exercise modality, intensity, and protocols.
- Need more research on sex differences, menstrual cycle effects, long-term use during high-volume training, periodized strategies, effects on fast-twitch fiber preservation, and bone health/injury risk in endurance athletes.
- Most data come from short loading protocols; chronic low-dose effects need clarification.

### Conclusion of the Review
Creatine supplementation has plausible mechanisms to support endurance performance, particularly by boosting anaerobic work capacity, repeated high-intensity efforts, and finishing kicks. It is **not** a general endurance booster for steady-state efforts and may even hinder weight-bearing activities due to body mass gain. However, it shows strong potential as a targeted aid for endurance sports involving surges, breakaways, or decisive end-spurts (e.g., cycling, mountain biking, rowing, kayaking, triathlon, cross-country skiing).

The review emphasizes that creatine is safe and can be a useful addition to an endurance athlete’s toolkit when used strategically.
 
It’s should be said since I see that “it’s safe” phrase used, it IS safe for healthy people. Period.

However, if you are diabetic or have kidney issues, you should work with doctors on it. It can put more load on the kidneys. Again, not a problem if you’re other wise healthy. It’s possible it can increase your creatinine levels, so if your doctor ask, just let them know you supplement with creatine.
 
Back
Top