As an engineer, I relate to the way Aaron thinks about problems and like listening to him as such. He is an arrogant person.
Most of the GW hate, I believe boils down to envy. People don’t like to see other people drop $15k on something they believe (likely valid) they can do themselves for $4k.
There are people for whom spending $4k vs $15k makes literally no difference. It is no better to spend less or to spend more on something, it’s all just relative. Many people don’t like hearing that.
I’ve had a GW setup. It was great. I no longer have one, and my current setup is great.
Anything past a Tikka with a reliable scope is essentially vanity. I have many and it’s fine, but doesn’t change anything practically. I enjoy nice things but what I wish most is that people would use what they have, and can afford, and go hunt and enjoy it, and spend less time worrying about what the internet says they need to be happy.
Also, I think the RS drop tests are a very practical approach with valid results.