CorbLand
WKR
- Joined
- Mar 16, 2016
- Messages
- 7,857
Nobody knows how long this is going to take. This is part of the problem from both sides. People want to know that April 21, at 12 noon this will all be over and we can move on but nobody knows. Eventually, we are going to have to go back to life as normal and eventually it will happen. When? I cant say and nobody can. What we do know is that not doing anything doesnt work very well.The other difficulty here is that the actions being taken affect everyone's life. We aren't playing a sum zero game here. How long does it take to get to 168,000,000 cases? It took 3 days to go from 50,000 to 100,000. It then took 6 days to go from 100,000 to 200,000. The trend in numbers keeps going to the right, increased doubling time. They keep moving the metric. When the lockdown talk started it was 2 weeks. That went to 4 weeks, its now gone to 8 weeks and beyond.
You keep the country shut down until we get into the lower quartile of herd immunity, you will cause a depression. That costs lives, that costs families, that cost livelihoods. Is a life saved from a virus worth more than one lost in the consequence? You do far too much your future could be a third world country.
The lockdown talk sounds great. It makes us feel safe. In your numbers assuming 50% will get it. Again, New York, assuming they are missing the mark by a factor of 10, they still have 46% of the population to go. Their healthcare system is overwhelmed at 4%. How long do you prolong this to get through the remaining 46% without overwhelming the system?
I dont know about other areas but the economy around here really isn't slowing down much. Restaurants are packed with people doing curbside pickup, most are still working from home and the the sporting goods store I work at met its sales goals 5 months early thanks to panic buying. Now, long term this could change but as of now, it looks ok. I think we will weather this pretty well and that the time we have bought has allowed hospitals to better prepare themselves.
As to your question of someone dying now versus someone dying later. Once again, we dont know that this will cause a depression to that level. What we know is what we can see at this point and sometimes you have attack what is in front of you and let the future be unknown.
Once again, I am not saying that I think what we are doing are the correct things but I think there is a way bigger picture than you are painting.
Last edited: