Thegman,
Eye relief on the 3x24 ACOG is short, but it's plenty for any AR cartridge I want to shoot. The field of view, however, is glorious. Much better than the 3x30 that offers long eye relief. I believe ACOGs are a unique product line that more people should consider, especially for specialized AR applications like this thread is dedicated to.
Another ACOG, the 1.5x16, is my go-to close range optic. I call it a red dot +P. With no batteries, an illuminated reticle, bulletproof housing, and just a tad of magnification for target ID, it's a wicked little optic.
Taudisio,
Once you test them side by side, you'll find out how much additional hunting time a magnified optic can provide. Depending on the scope, it can be significant. The best I've used is Trijicon's 2.5-10x56mm, and that hideously large scope delivered an impressive amount of light. But even a basic 3-9X might give an additional 5 minutes of shooting light compared to a red dot.
Note that scout scopes don't work the same way. I believe this is because of the extreme eye relief. Regardless, they don't buy you time like a traditionally-mounted optic does.