To each his own... there are a lot of things I like about the tenmile ffp hx reticle, and few that I don't. I'm looking through mine at last light (last 7 minutes of legal shooting light at the moment). Reticle is easy to pick up even not illuminated, at 3x and 18x. Love the floating center dot, for some reason it just works for me for being more precise shooting groups, i like it better than the floating cross hair in the nxs, but it's a close margin. I don't use the "tree" much, but I'd personally rather have it and not need it, than to not have it and need it...