- Thread Starter
- #61
Pointing out the flaws in the arrow performance isn’t me absolving myself of any responsibility, just to clarify. Arrow 1 was not placed perfect that much is sure. Had I slipped it through a rib right into the heart or lungs problem solved game over I have a dead bull on my hands with no drama, regardless of arrow shot.
Arrow 2 is the one I’m a little surprised everyone isn’t too concerned about. I’ve only put arrows in 3 elk and 5 mule deer bucks. So don’t have all the experience. Is glancing off ribs at under 20 yards normal for many of you? Is that an acceptable expected outcome? That’s the one I think people are glancing over. There was no deflection off a branch the front of the bull was behind a young pine tree but it had clearly defined edges and I was in the wide open. The arrow went right where it was aimed. Should have been a clean pass through double lung. Instead I got one lung then liver and gut as it deflected back and up. Rib was clearly impacted upon entering. Throw shot number 1 out the window if that helps people stay more objective. Shot 2 for me is unacceptable performance. Not unacceptable shot placement but performance. (The way the bull spun after being hit would have resulted in the opposite angle if he did indeed move before the arrow arrived). I want something that at least gives a full reliable pass through on that shot. Also, yes I’m aware that the setup and lesser setups can indeed kill elk. Cleaning the skull of one such elk right at this moment, so keenly aware.
Do some of you just accept pretty extreme rib deflections as part of the game when elk hunting? Do you just hope you don’t hit a rib or any bone for that matter?
Arrow 2 is the one I’m a little surprised everyone isn’t too concerned about. I’ve only put arrows in 3 elk and 5 mule deer bucks. So don’t have all the experience. Is glancing off ribs at under 20 yards normal for many of you? Is that an acceptable expected outcome? That’s the one I think people are glancing over. There was no deflection off a branch the front of the bull was behind a young pine tree but it had clearly defined edges and I was in the wide open. The arrow went right where it was aimed. Should have been a clean pass through double lung. Instead I got one lung then liver and gut as it deflected back and up. Rib was clearly impacted upon entering. Throw shot number 1 out the window if that helps people stay more objective. Shot 2 for me is unacceptable performance. Not unacceptable shot placement but performance. (The way the bull spun after being hit would have resulted in the opposite angle if he did indeed move before the arrow arrived). I want something that at least gives a full reliable pass through on that shot. Also, yes I’m aware that the setup and lesser setups can indeed kill elk. Cleaning the skull of one such elk right at this moment, so keenly aware.
Do some of you just accept pretty extreme rib deflections as part of the game when elk hunting? Do you just hope you don’t hit a rib or any bone for that matter?
Last edited: