I think Idaho’s tag sale works due to date and demand. They sell before all the other states, and they have a system that gives you a decent chance at some kind of tag. The other states are later and a crap shoot to get a tag.
Used to be you went to Idaho if you didnt draw anywhere else. Now you buy Idaho first, and if you then draw better you turn it back in.
A draw would have folks boxed in to a choice or two. And then low demand stuff may not get applicants while trying for higher demand stuff.
I think they just need to organize it better.
Maybe have you buy the license first like some other states do. And limit tbe tag mules and multiple log-ins.