I honestly will sweat on my lower legs from walking in them. My lower legs will almost be as wet as if I was walking through wet grass without gaiters. That being said I use them more often than not.I've never understood the complaint about the heat with gaiters. Do people's lower legs really overheat in any temps? I've worn them in triple digit heat on the Plains and over heated lower legs never even crossed my mind. So September in the high country chasing elk all over the mountains isn't an issue at all with gaiters, and I wear the Yukons (the tall ones).
I too use mine as a dry working surface in the TP. I wear mine almost all the time. I don't have a problem with heat. If I am going to carry them anyway, I will carry them on my feet instead of adding to my pack weight. The only time I will ditch is when the days are guaranteed warm and dry all day.And, at night, when you need to stand up from your bivy or from out of your tarp to piss, gaiters provide you a clean, dry surface to stand on.
Listen it's ok to wear gaiters to look bad ass.
I think Rinella had something like that on one of his podcasts. Wherever I heard it I had a good laugh.
any recommendations on a pair?