Unpopular opinions

[Muleys32]

Cellular trail cameras should have a mandatory 1 week delay on all photo deliveries for any hunting application.

 

[cmahoney]

Guided hunts are just as tough as DIY


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Pony Soldier]

This goes back a couple pages - - I was raised with " beef is for selling - elk is for eating".

 

[Coopsdaddy]

Good mid priced optics =Zeiss conquest hd

 

[ezwy]

State's rights are important. Resident hunting perks are are a privilege of living in a state that manages their game well.

 

[Ralphie]

If you are a hunter because it looked cool on Youtube then you aren't really a hunter.

 

[IdahoBeav]

Replaceable blade knives suck

Blacktails are the easiest deer to hunt

Hinge releases are awesome for hunting (this is gaining some popularity recently)

Nymph fishing is boring and for noobs

Idaho has the best nonresident tag sale process

 

[Huntindog45]

Replaceable blade knives suck

Blacktails are the easiest deer to hunt

Hinge releases are awesome for hunting (this is gaining some popularity recently)

Nymph fishing is boring and for noobs

Idaho has the best nonresident tag sale process

oh hell yah..i hate replaceable blade knives, I keep one in my pack just in case... but i really do hate using the thing. However I would argue about nymph fishing. I love dry fly fishing but i will outfish most dry fly guys (self included) 10:1 with nymphs. even in the middle of a great hatch... or maybe especially in the middle of a great hatch. Black tails.. yes and no. I get two tags here in California.. one where i hunt primarily public land. I hunt my ass off for a decent buck, usually get one but its tough hunting. My other cali tag I get to hunt some cool private land and it is basically grocery shopping. So pressure matters.

 

[IdahoBeav]

However I would argue about nymph fishing. I love dry fly fishing but i will outfish most dry fly guys (self included) 10:1 with nymphs. even in the middle of a great hatch... or maybe especially in the middle of a great hatch.

If it was all about catching fish, then you might as well fish with standard gear.

If dries aren't getting them, it's time to grab the 7 wt, 1x, and streamers.

 

[KurtR]

Versatile dogs are jacks of all trades but master of none

 

[PredatorSlayer]

Tikkas suck and are over rated.

The Rokstok might be the ugliest thing I have ever seen and don’t think its worth the money they are charging.

The new MRC Marshall seems like a huge waste of money. They still sell MRC rifles on gunbroker with free Africa hunts because they can’t move them. You are paying an additional $2k for QC is what it amounts to.

 

[Swamp Fox]

[...]

Also, Rememeber when we used to celebrate things like Meateater for increasing adult onset hunters because they were increasing the amount of people that would be a support for hunters at the ballet box.....? [...]

Sir, this is a Rokslide forum.

Let's leave Meateater and ballet out of it ...

 

[Sbird2019]

Shooting North American game in or right behind the crease is not the perfect broadside shot and we should stop teaching that. Most people, especially inexperienced hunters, shooting for the “crease” actually aim at the shadow of the crease and they’ll almost always shoot further back on the animal and miss the heart and just get double lung (still lethal yes, but more margin for error and tracking)

In reality, if they shoot an inch in front of the crease, that’s a dead center heart shot

 

[TaperPin]

To test the fun meter with nymph vs dry flies, a 1st grader visiting the house was very interested in watching me tie flies, so I had them design and tie their own. Kids love arts and crafts and after the crude legs and round fuzzy body, what I assumed would turn out like a black beetle or nymph of some kind actually matched a big house fly with a big crude wing. We waterproofed it, went to the local kids pond and on the very first attempt at a roll cast had multiple takes, which were so exciting it caused the new fly caster to freeze, unable to talk, move, or set the hook at all. Anything that causes total immobilization from the excitement of the moment pegs the fun meter. lol

 

[Truck24hr]

What are some commonly held beliefs in the hunting world that you don’t agree with?

Bipods. Eff me.

Maybe I'm just bitchin cause I don't wanna drop the coin, but I used to kill game, and shoot 1000 yard matches with a 70$ Harris bipod.

Now I'm not sure I could shoot 100 yards without a 500$ bipod.

 

[TSAMP]

Versatile dogs are jacks of all trades but master of none

Clearly you've never seen what my versatile does with a throw pillow

 

[highcountrymuley]

Rare game meat is gross! I know it cannot be overcooked but I don't like the texture of chewy rare meat.

 

[bozeman]

Unmatching camo = soft core hunter

 

[goathunter]

No wild animal will EVER beat a well raised American steer.

I'll take elk chops over beef any day

 

[samhelmer]

At this point I will forever say run just to make grown men upset on the internet.

You certainly do act like a fly fisherman.