Stone sheep beware

Joined
Feb 7, 2023
Messages
14
Long time follower of this site and forgot my password from before. As most of you know by now stone sheep have become one of the hardest hunts to fulfill due to physical requirements, financial commitment and limited availability on sheep in general. Please keep in mind that I am a person who seldom complains and I have no issue with coming home empty handed on hunts if I am giving it all I can. I spend 40+ nights a year doing solo backpack trips and hunts. This is not just me having issues. I know for a fact that most of the hunters would never return to this outfit even if they were successful. I’m choosing not to name the outfitter as I hope most people will do their research extensively and ask for several references prior to booking.

In summary for those who don’t want the long version.
-paid for horseback hunt and forced to backpack for 17 days on first year due poor management (plenty of horses to ride) and lack of guides
-given guide who had never guided the area or been in the area (great guide but no experience in area)
-disgruntled ex owner/ex crew had allegedly disclosed to residents better areas to find rams (we ran into several residents)
-forced to ration food for 5 days as ex outfitter had left us after giving us a boat ride into area. Owner had no other person to run boat and didn’t want to pay for a charter boat.
- Ran out of food for several days and strung out on food drop due to owner being unwilling to pay for a food drop
-forced to stay in the area 12 days longer due to no boat ride available back to camp to get horses (3-4 day walk to main camp)
-given 16 year old packer who couldn’t pack his own weight and offered zero benefit to hunt. Who spent most days in camp eating all of our food and was in tears while he was on the trail.
-zero opportunity on legal rams in 32 days
-owner falsely advertises success rates and includes confiscated rams into their success rates
-owner has had three outfitters operate concession in three years and at least two of those have chose to separate themselves from the owner (owners girlfriend now has outfitter license to operate area and knows very little about hunting, horses and outfitter logistics)
-regrettably paid outfitter (even after not receiving a horseback hunt that I had paid for) to return the following year (met cool guide and wrangler but they also chose to leave and will not come back)
-owner takes zero accountability and says he has no control what his outfitters chose to do
-during second trip the existing outfitter parted with owner. Most all of the crew will not be returning.
-I’m nearly 6 figures into this one animal
-owner continues to falsely advertise success rates and includes confiscated rams into the “success rates”
I have had the experience over the last two years of putting in over 32 days on these animals with a once reputable outfitter prior to sale. I wanted to share my experience because I know most people could be put in the same situation as me. There has been several outfits changing hands in the stone sheep world and prices have gone crazy in just a few years.

I booked my sheep hunt in 2019, with Covid the original family who had run the outfit chose to sell. Come 2021 it was iffy if the hunt was going to be a go or not. A month or so prior to the hunt we had been given the green light. I got vaccinated and was making final preparations. Upon arrival my outfitter picked me up and told me he was leaving the operation due to disagreements with the owner. He said we would be taking a new outfitter into the area the next day to take over and that I shouldn’t worry as I would have a good hunt still. He had some disagreements with the owner and the owner had fired his help and also fired the old owner who knew the area and the horses. This guy was decent to me and said he had a hunt to finish up and then he was heading out. He helped get us into our area as he was the only one who could drive the jet boat.

Upon arrival to camp I could sense the tension. Several members of the crew had quit over the summer. As I booked a horseback hunt I had expected to be riding out of camp. Instead we were told we would be backpacking for the first 5 days and then we would return to camp and get horses if needed. I met my guide who had never guided the area and my packer who was a nice kid but had never been on a backpacking trip as a packer.

We packed for 5 days planning on a short trip into a corner of the property. Ended up very early on into this trip realizing the packer was unfit for this position and had to deal with him in tears several times a day and just not mentally fit for this hunt (nice kid who should have never been put in this position).

We ended up being stuck in this area for the duration of my hunt. We hunted hard every day and covered some amazing country. In all we out over 135 foot miles down and broke trail on places that hadn’t been seen in what I would assume to be years. We tried making the best of our situation even though my guide and I knew we had a major disadvantage by not being on horses.

The outfitter who no longer runs the operation called and said it would be best if I come back the following year as some more of the crew had quit mid season due to disagreements with the owner. The owner told me I would need to come back this season in order to not have to pay half of the hunt cost. He also told me he would have never sold the hunt to me for what the old owner did (I paid full price).

I argued that I didn’t think it was fair to have to pay again even though I had already paid for a horseback hunt with an experienced guide and packer. He told me that this was something he had no control over.

During my time in the area we ran into at least a dozen residents. Some who were actually ex guides of the area, even they were disappointed in the lack of sheep in general and told me stories about the good old days in the area. Some of the more bitter guides that had left earlier in the season had told their resident friends where sheep are generally found as well. I experienced this first hand, not hearsay.

To be continued…
 
Joined
Oct 10, 2021
Messages
5
Long time follower of this site and forgot my password from before. As most of you know by now stone sheep have become one of the hardest hunts to fulfill due to physical requirements, financial commitment and limited availability on sheep in general. Please keep in mind that I am a person who seldom complains and I have no issue with coming home empty handed on hunts if I am giving it all I can. I spend 40+ nights a year doing solo backpack trips and hunts. This is not just me having issues. I know for a fact that most of the hunters would never return to this outfit even if they were successful. I’m choosing not to name the outfitter as I hope most people will do their research extensively and ask for several references prior to booking.

In summary for those who don’t want the long version.
-paid for horseback hunt and forced to backpack for 17 days on first year due poor management (plenty of horses to ride) and lack of guides
-given guide who had never guided the area or been in the area (great guide but no experience in area)
-disgruntled ex owner/ex crew had allegedly disclosed to residents better areas to find rams (we ran into several residents)
-forced to ration food for 5 days as ex outfitter had left us after giving us a boat ride into area. Owner had no other person to run boat and didn’t want to pay for a charter boat.
- Ran out of food for several days and strung out on food drop due to owner being unwilling to pay for a food drop
-forced to stay in the area 12 days longer due to no boat ride available back to camp to get horses (3-4 day walk to main camp)
-given 16 year old packer who couldn’t pack his own weight and offered zero benefit to hunt. Who spent most days in camp eating all of our food and was in tears while he was on the trail.
-zero opportunity on legal rams in 32 days
-owner falsely advertises success rates and includes confiscated rams into their success rates
-owner has had three outfitters operate concession in three years and at least two of those have chose to separate themselves from the owner (owners girlfriend now has outfitter license to operate area and knows very little about hunting, horses and outfitter logistics)
-regrettably paid outfitter (even after not receiving a horseback hunt that I had paid for) to return the following year (met cool guide and wrangler but they also chose to leave and will not come back)
-owner takes zero accountability and says he has no control what his outfitters chose to do
-during second trip the existing outfitter parted with owner. Most all of the crew will not be returning.
-I’m nearly 6 figures into this one animal
-owner continues to falsely advertise success rates and includes confiscated rams into the “success rates”
I have had the experience over the last two years of putting in over 32 days on these animals with a once reputable outfitter prior to sale. I wanted to share my experience because I know most people could be put in the same situation as me. There has been several outfits changing hands in the stone sheep world and prices have gone crazy in just a few years.

I booked my sheep hunt in 2019, with Covid the original family who had run the outfit chose to sell. Come 2021 it was iffy if the hunt was going to be a go or not. A month or so prior to the hunt we had been given the green light. I got vaccinated and was making final preparations. Upon arrival my outfitter picked me up and told me he was leaving the operation due to disagreements with the owner. He said we would be taking a new outfitter into the area the next day to take over and that I shouldn’t worry as I would have a good hunt still. He had some disagreements with the owner and the owner had fired his help and also fired the old owner who knew the area and the horses. This guy was decent to me and said he had a hunt to finish up and then he was heading out. He helped get us into our area as he was the only one who could drive the jet boat.

Upon arrival to camp I could sense the tension. Several members of the crew had quit over the summer. As I booked a horseback hunt I had expected to be riding out of camp. Instead we were told we would be backpacking for the first 5 days and then we would return to camp and get horses if needed. I met my guide who had never guided the area and my packer who was a nice kid but had never been on a backpacking trip as a packer.

We packed for 5 days planning on a short trip into a corner of the property. Ended up very early on into this trip realizing the packer was unfit for this position and had to deal with him in tears several times a day and just not mentally fit for this hunt (nice kid who should have never been put in this position).

We ended up being stuck in this area for the duration of my hunt. We hunted hard every day and covered some amazing country. In all we out over 135 foot miles down and broke trail on places that hadn’t been seen in what I would assume to be years. We tried making the best of our situation even though my guide and I knew we had a major disadvantage by not being on horses.

The outfitter who no longer runs the operation called and said it would be best if I come back the following year as some more of the crew had quit mid season due to disagreements with the owner. The owner told me I would need to come back this season in order to not have to pay half of the hunt cost. He also told me he would have never sold the hunt to me for what the old owner did (I paid full price).

I argued that I didn’t think it was fair to have to pay again even though I had already paid for a horseback hunt with an experienced guide and packer. He told me that this was something he had no control over.

During my time in the area we ran into at least a dozen residents. Some who were actually ex guides of the area, even they were disappointed in the lack of sheep in general and told me stories about the good old days in the area. Some of the more bitter guides that had left earlier in the season had told their resident friends where sheep are generally found as well. I experienced this first hand, not hearsay.

To be continued…

From the sounds of it I can guess the outfitter , heard similar story’s in 2021.
 
OP
S
Joined
Feb 7, 2023
Messages
14
Hey guys, I didn’t expect to get this many views this quick. I don’t know what the site rules are.

I’ll accept the criticism for going with them again, but this was a once in a lifetime hunt. The outfitter who took it over gave me a hundred percent confidence that I would have a good experience on my second trip. So rather than paying for a hunt with a new outfitter (I couldn’t spend that money twice) I chose to go back and take my chances. The sad reality is this is a once in a lifetime experience and I just hope others will do more research on these outfitters.

There are probably no less than a hundred people who know what outfitter this is. I’m happy to respond to a private message regarding this.
 

Rob5589

WKR
Joined
Sep 6, 2014
Messages
6,243
Location
N CA
Your story is like so many others; didn't do your research, had a bad experience, sign up on a forum to complain, keep the name to yourself. You do get a bonus point for going a second time though. So there's that...
 
OP
S
Joined
Feb 7, 2023
Messages
14
I would disagree about not doing my research. The previous owner that I booked with had it in their family for almost 20 years. They had good success rates and a solid reputation. This was sold without my knowledge and with no communication from the prior owner. My deposit was nonrefundable at that point in time.
 

HornPorn

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
Oct 7, 2020
Messages
292
"owner has had three outfitters operate concession in three years and at least two of those have chose to separate themselves from the owner"

Then you say, you booked with the outfitter who had been running it for 20 years.

So if you booked with outfitter "20", then you didn't hunt with them, you hunted with outfitter #2, or #3. Then, who did you go with on your second hunt, the same outfitter, or a different one?

Seems clear as mud as to who your beef is actually with, and this thread was pointless without naming the owner/outfitter you are unhappy with. Seems like the owner is the one causing the turnover....outfitter #2 and #3 understandably would have some growing pains and not have things dialed in given those things take time.
 

WCB

WKR
Joined
Jun 12, 2019
Messages
3,279
Name the outfitter...Once in a lifetime hunt....you went/paid twice? I'm confused. Even you got the best guide and horses the second trip did you think there would all of a sudden be legal rams every where and less people?
 
OP
S
Joined
Feb 7, 2023
Messages
14
Yeah, sorry that wasn’t clear. I was basically committed to the new owner even though I’d booked with the old owner.
My complaint isn’t with any of the outfitters who have ran it. It’s with the owner. I’m upset I spent the money to go again but a hunt for a third of the price of a new one seemed like a good idea. We hunted hard the second time around and I had a great guide and wrangler. Got the horseback hunt I’ve always dreamed of. I was basically committed an opening if someone didn’t tag.
So when an opening came available the owner sold a cancellation instead of letting me come hunt. Fortunately/unfortunately another hunter was unsuccessful so then I was called to come hunt.
 

Steve O

WKR
Classified Approved
Joined
Feb 29, 2012
Messages
2,911
Location
Michigan
You should change the title of your thread. Beware of whom? Right now you are telling a fairy tale with no point. Sounds like a rough one though.
 

Steve O

WKR
Classified Approved
Joined
Feb 29, 2012
Messages
2,911
Location
Michigan
can we at least get a province? I’m assuming BC, but there are a couple to watch out for in the Yukon as well.
 
Top