Got ya. Sorry I didn't get read the original post. Yeah it's a truly tough topic. I live in Colorado. We've had a season last 2 years. It's only good in theory. They also don't restrict any other activities. Only shed hunting. Most don't follow the rules which sucks. Also May IMO is too late.In response to having a shed season and having to get a shed hunting license.
IMO to work. They need to have a floating start date based on the severity of the winter. Could start as early as April 1 or as late as May 1. There's grass growing up to my shins in places by the time we can go look. An they need to close heavy winter ranges for animals to all forms of recreation. That way they can have a higher chance at enforcing the season. If they don't then unless they directly catch someone that person can just say they weren't looking for Antler. They still catch some guys but most get away.
That's my 2 cents on having a season. I for one don't think it works. I also think shed hunting can be done responsibly enough not to pressure animals. There are many tactics you can use to have very low impact.