Rokstaff Hunt 'n Success Photos

OP
robby denning

robby denning

Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Feb 25, 2012
Messages
15,687
Location
SE Idaho
Tag #1, Tag #2,
ha ha. we're just hoping to fill one every few years! Way to stack 'em up Ross. Love your hunting style.
 

Tony Trietch

Part Time Bow Hiker
Staff member
Joined
Jul 28, 2013
Messages
2,127
Location
Northern MI, USA
Kansas is treating me well as usual.
b0f5af3f265928d9ff2b539c39619a6e.jpg

9756be58bae679ee5f716a907024df75.jpg

c68dcb7c7f575833e563e6c4f72e7e74.jpg



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Jared Bloomgren

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Feb 25, 2012
Messages
936
"Let Them Grow - Shoot a Doe!"

With a month long season I was able to put in ample time trying to find a mature buck of my choice to wrap my tag around. It involved many hours and miles scouring the Black Hills of SD in search of that monster buck that everyone is after. I passed on numerous bucks that didn't meet the criteria and should really be given a chance of turning into trophies. I understand everyone's definition of a trophy varies a great deal. Most bucks I passed would have been trophies for many others. To each their own...

It came down to the final day with putting in 19.4 miles and passing on six bucks from sunrise to sunset and was able to fill my tag in the final few minutes of the season with a BIG healthy good table fare doe! Very happy of this kill! She was well earned and I was more than happy to take a doe rather than a buck!

With this tag you have the option to shoot any sex deer. There are plenty of does, too many to be honest; so taking a doe was best for the management of this area I feel. I wish more did that rather than shoot a small, immature buck just to say they shot a buck. Heck, the doe eats better anyway!

attachment.php
 
Last edited:
OP
robby denning

robby denning

Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Feb 25, 2012
Messages
15,687
Location
SE Idaho
Jared, thanks for having a pair big enough to post this! Too many high-profile hunters are a little leery to post up that they shoot a doe. Yet by shooting that doe instead of a small buck, you actually help the buck:doe ratio instead of hurt it. Good on you...

As I said on your FB post, there's some very old faulty thinking out there when it comes to harvesting does. People think we're raising cattle "and you can't shoot the mammas!", but cattle have virtually limitless "habitat" (it's called a haystack) but wild game is limited by the amount of natural habitat (that is mostly shrinking).

Some of the best mule deer hunting of yesteryear occurred under either-sex hunting rules. Now we force a segment of the hunters to shoot a buck under bucks-only regulations when many of them would be happy with a doe.

I've shot many does over my hunting career. Even this year, I was ready to shoot one last eve if things hadn't turned for the better. In SE Idaho, we have a lot of does right now and when a hard winter hits, the remaining bucks will have to compete with all those does for survival.

I'm not saying every mule deer herd can support doe harvest, but many can and should have doe harvest (lots of guys are surprised to find out our best mule deer state for herd size and antler size offers many doe tags in a lot of units- Colorado).

If the good biology says it's acceptable, I support it. When the herd is balanced with habitat, everything just works better- healthier fawns that are born on time, better buck:doe ratios, and even better antler growth.

Thanks for posting this!
 

Jared Bloomgren

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Feb 25, 2012
Messages
936
I thought I had posted this picture already!

I was lucky enough to go back to MT again this year after mule deer. Very happy to find a buck that I had saw last year that I passed up while he was tending a doe. He grew nearly 20" from the year before and was located very near the same chunk of BLM land that he was on the previous year!

Gotta love proper management!

attachment.php
 

Jared Bloomgren

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Feb 25, 2012
Messages
936
Sondra, my fiance' was lucky enough to draw a late season SD muzzloader tag and we were able to turn up this buck after putting on many foot miles in less than 0 degree weather! She is stubborn or very dedicated, one of the two, as she wouldn't let me help pack the buck out! She carried all the boned out meat, head and cape back to the vehicle in her pack! What gives?! Naw, I am very proud of her accomplishments!

attachment.php
 
Top