Protocols: what to do with meat while CWD test is pending?

No sure about that. The spinal cord is inside the vertebrae right? I'm not cutting through the spinal cord or any bones. I am cutting the meat away from the spinal processess.. Enlighten me?
Yea, I'm not seeing any spinal fluid while cutting out backstraps...

When do you freeze/wet age, at what stage of processing, etc?
I would start eating it immediately, but since you mention wet aging... I've had good results wet aging deer and elk up to 30days(vac sealed in the fridge). I've done it to tenderize it, but also because we had limited freezer room in our camper for a couple of weeks we were on the road.
 
I could be wrong......

Sent from my SM-S931U using Tapatalk

There is nothing to enlighten. To quote myself, I could be wrong. Maybe I am. I have no idea where exactly spinal fluid is and isn't.

Sent from my SM-S931U using Tapatalk
 
It seems likely that processing with a professional increases the risk of cross contamination with CWD positive meat. I don't think that is a guarantee, but your post brings up a good point. There is likely more CWD exposure to humans than positive animal cases suggest.
I wouldn't say it's an increased risk. I would say it's a guarantee based on how prions are actually destroyed.
 
It can't just leak out into muscle tissues, it's contained unless there's damage from bullets or knives and such.
So spinal fluid is contained 100% inside the spinal column? Its not in sacs, veins or tendon like structures running along the entire spinal area? its not present in between vertebrae in pockets? Genuine question.

Edit, to be even more clear, there is no chance of cutting or puncturing something that contains spinal fluid when carving out a backstrap?
 
So spinal fluid is contained 100% inside the spinal column? Its not in sacs, veins or tendon like structures running along the entire spinal area? its not present in between vertebrae in pockets? Genuine question.

Edit, to be even more clear, there is no chance of cutting or puncturing something that contains spinal fluid when carving out a backstrap?
I'm not a surgeon but as a layman I believe it's contained, no reason for it to be in sacks or veins or anything outside of the spine. I would think you'd have to cut between the vertebrae to release the fluids, or obviously bullet or bone shrapnel can damage it and cause a leak. The lymph node system can obviously accumulate the prions though as that's actually what they collect to test I think so there's obviously other tissues that can contain the prions and not just spinal fluid.
 
I'm not a surgeon but as a layman I believe it's contained, no reason for it to be in sacks or veins or anything outside of the spine. I would think you'd have to cut between the vertebrae to release the fluids, or obviously bullet or bone shrapnel can damage it and cause a leak. The lymph node system can obviously accumulate the prions though as that's actually what they collect to test I think so there's obviously other tissues that can contain the prions and not just spinal fluid.
Maybe its the lymph system that I am thinking of. I just thought I distinctly remember it being said that there is a chance of contaminating meat with prions while removing backstraps. Again, I could be wrong about all of it and just mis remembering.

Sent from my SM-S931U using Tapatalk
 
Maybe its the lymph system that I am thinking of. I just thought I distinctly remember it being said that there is a chance of contaminating meat with prions while removing backstraps. Again, I could be wrong about all of it and just mis remembering.

Sent from my SM-S931U using Tapatalk
The lymph system goes all over the body, so theoretically any tissue there is a risk of contamination.

Logically, neck meat to me poses the highest risk, but in reality as long as you are not sawing through bones/spine/etc the risk with skeletal muscle is very low. Also logically, I think consuming organs would increase risk
 
CWD prions cannot be destroyed using any method that you, or a butcher has available. 100% without question if you take your meat to a butcher it has got CWD prions in it. Not only that- your knife has prions from animals- do you throw away your knife after using it while waiting for the results to come back? What about your gloves? Shirt, pants? What about your boots? They have prions on them as well. Being that animals shed CWD through fecal matter and urine- if you walk in the field you will get prions.
Also, what about vegetables? When animals with CWD walk through those vegetables growing, and defecate they are shedding prions.


The monument you think logically about this in the most basic manner, is the moment you realize that you already have CWD prions on you and in you.
 
CWD prions cannot be destroyed using any method that you, or a butcher has available. 100% without question if you take your meat to a burger it has got CWD prions in it. Not only that- your knife has prions from animals- do you throw away your knife after using it while waiting for the results to come back? What about your gloves? Shirt, pants? What about your boots? They have prions on them as well. Being that animals shed CWD through fecal matter and urine- if you walk in the field you will get prions.
Also, what about vegetables? When animals with CWD walk through those vegetables growing, and defecate they are shedding prions.


The monument you think logically about this in the most basic manner, is the moment you realize that you already have CWD prions on you and in you.
Why are you so sure that bleach doesn't deactivate prions? The Univerity of Wyoming as well as Biologists at WY GF told me that 40% solution of house hold bleach deactivated prions. But I've heard a bunch of people say it doesn't ?

The rest of what you have said really makes sense. Im starting to debate just pretending like CWD doesn't exist and throwing my whole protocol out the window. I probably won't, but I really should.

Sent from my SM-S931U using Tapatalk
 
Why are you so sure that bleach doesn't deactivate prions? The Univerity of Wyoming as well as Biologists at WY GF told me that 40% solution of house hold bleach deactivated prions. But I've heard a bunch of people say it doesn't ?

The rest of what you have said really makes sense. Im starting to debate just pretending like CWD doesn't exist and throwing my whole protocol out the window. I probably won't, but I really should.

Sent from my SM-S931U using Tapatalk


Look up research on prions. Potentially on steel (non porous surfaces), bleach for a relatively long period can inactivate the prions- though that is not agreed upon across the board and it doesn’t work functionally anything else…. So you are still getting prions transfer. Otherwise it is extreme heat.

Prions are not a bacteria or a virus and people seem to have a hard time understanding that they aren’t “killable”. If CWD is a real threat to humans - we already have it.
 
CWD prions cannot be destroyed using any method that you, or a butcher has available. 100% without question if you take your meat to a butcher it has got CWD prions in it. Not only that- your knife has prions from animals- do you throw away your knife after using it while waiting for the results to come back? What about your gloves? Shirt, pants? What about your boots? They have prions on them as well. Being that animals shed CWD through fecal matter and urine- if you walk in the field you will get prions.
Also, what about vegetables? When animals with CWD walk through those vegetables growing, and defecate they are shedding prions.


The monument you think logically about this in the most basic manner, is the moment you realize that you already have CWD prions on you and in you.
You bring up a good point. I should build a hermetically sealed bubble to hunt in.

I'm just going to have trouble pulling the trigger (literally) :LOL:

There are obviously CWD positive and negative cases, so not every dang thing is covered in prions to the extent that all deer are infected. I appreciate your boots on the ground perspective though. I think it's reasonable to avoid CWD positive meat or disregard the risk entirely, depending on one's risk tolerance. I say that because of scientific input I've read on the subject, which might have it's own bias or issues...

"At least with current CWD strains, there is a high species barrier, but it certainly doesn't mean that it [spillover] isn't possible or that the threshold of the species barrier might not change in the future when CWD strains evolve." -Director of the National Prion Disease Pathology Surveillance Center at Case Western Reserve University

There is no doubt that prion diseases can and do evolve. We just can't say when or if that will ever happen to the extent that they pass to human beings. I guess that's why it's such an annoying forum topic haha!

Really appreciate your contributions to hunting at large, Form! I've learned a lot between the scope, suppressor, and bullet subject matter. I would actually consider bleaching my knife and tossing my game bags if an animal was positive (anything that would likely come into contact with meat down the line).
 
You bring up a good point. I should build a hermetically sealed bubble to hunt in.

I'm just going to have trouble pulling the trigger (literally) :LOL:

There are obviously CWD positive and negative cases, so not every dang thing is covered in prions to the extent that all deer are infected. I appreciate your boots on the ground perspective though. I think it's reasonable to avoid CWD positive meat or disregard the risk entirely, depending on one's risk tolerance. I say that because of scientific input I've read on the subject, which might have it's own bias or issues...

"At least with current CWD strains, there is a high species barrier, but it certainly doesn't mean that it [spillover] isn't possible or that the threshold of the species barrier might not change in the future when CWD strains evolve." -Director of the National Prion Disease Pathology Surveillance Center at Case Western Reserve University

There is no doubt that prion diseases can and do evolve. We just can't say when or if that will ever happen to the extent that they pass to human beings. I guess that's why it's such an annoying forum topic haha!

Really appreciate your contributions to hunting at large, Form! I've learned a lot between the scope, suppressor, and bullet subject matter. I would actually consider bleaching my knife and tossing my game bags if an animal was positive (anything that would likely come into contact with meat down the line).


Absolutely that’s what sucks about prions. There is no clear way to actually and legitimately deal with CWD prions now- they are literally on everything where animals with CWD exist. Some animals seem to be more resistant to CWD, and it can take years for effects to show up.

Either CWD in this major disaster and is a major problem in which case we are already screwed no matter what. Or, we aren’t screwed no matter what, which means it isn’t a major issue to humans.
 
Look up research on prions. Potentially on steel (non porous surfaces), bleach for a relatively long period can inactivate the prions- though that is not agreed upon across the board and it doesn’t work functionally anything else…. So you are still getting prions transfer. Otherwise it is extreme heat.

Prions are not a bacteria or a virus and people seem to have a hard time understanding that they aren’t “killable”. If CWD is a real threat to humans - we already have it.
The only thing I cant get a clear answer on in regards to surfaces being contaminated with prions, is to what extent? If they can't be cleaned off, killed, deactivated, ect, for how long are they transferring from one surface to another? If I butcher a positive animal on a countertop, it can't leave an unlimited amount of prions behind. Is it leaving any prions at all? I thought they werent really present in meat. At some point they woukd all be gone, and if they cant be removed with cleaning, then how are they transferring at all?

Sent from my SM-S931U using Tapatalk
 
We take CWD seriously as it’s been in my area for years and about 1 out of 4 test positive. We have killed or found quite a few sick deer. I quarter and freeze or I have aged quarters in my fridge. Most people I know will not eat a positive. As long as it tests negative and the deer appeared healthy I don’t worry too much about it.
 
Why are you so sure that bleach doesn't deactivate prions? The Univerity of Wyoming as well as Biologists at WY GF told me that 40% solution of house hold bleach deactivated prions. But I've heard a bunch of people say it doesn't ?

The rest of what you have said really makes sense. Im starting to debate just pretending like CWD doesn't exist and throwing my whole protocol out the window. I probably won't, but I really should.

Sent from my SM-S931U using Tapatalk

I worked at a major medical center years ago, we wouldn’t even do autopsies, much less surgery/biopsies, when a prion dz was suspected. It would require everything/anything touching used to be destroyed. Granted different prions.
 
I worked at a major medical center years ago, we wouldn’t even do autopsies, much less surgery/biopsies, when a prion dz was suspected. It would require everything/anything touching used to be destroyed. Granted different prions.

Point being, we don’t know of any human cross over. Don’t eat sick looking animals, I have no desire to know if an animal is carrying CWD.
 
Back
Top