One and Done Action.

[flyfisher117]

A Tikka oughta check those boxes for you.

Then I can’t brag at the water cooler.

 

[Yaremkiv]

Then I can’t brag at the water cooler.

 

[WildBoose]

Oh. You mean one of those

Then I can’t brag at the water cooler.

You could do something with other men at the water cooler, but bragging isn’t it.

 

[flyfisher117]

You could do something with other men at the water cooler, but bragging isn’t it.

That’s what Savage shooters do.

 

[ghostrider272]

Pure Precision SKLTN. Was looking at several of the brands you mentioned, but to a chance on the PP and am very happy I did.

 

[Yaremkiv]

That’s what Savage shooters do.

We found a point of agreement. We're not so different you and I.

 

[DangerRanger]

At this point upsetting the Team Tikka Fanboys is ranking pretty high on my list of things to care about. Even tho I own them myself.

Unreal really, similar to this:
OP
“Looking for a 3/4ton diesel to pull my camper”
Replies
“MY F150 would pull it just fine!”
“Don’t need a diesel gas is just fine!”
“Why do you even have camper”
“Have you considered selling it and buying an RV”

Some people just want to voice their opinions even if it doesn’t pertain to the topic….welcome to the forum world I suppose.

I guess,I think your analogy is a bit off personally. There are absolute and clear reasons for 1/2 vs 3/4 vs 1 ton trucks in use case and I don’t think it’s analogous to actions at all.

As I said previously, you asked what we would buy and that’s not what you wanted to know

I don’t think many people here at “upset” I think many have owned most of the actions on your list and don’t think of them as “better”

 

[TxLite]

As I said previously, you asked what we would buy and that’s not what you wanted to know

Dude let it go. Literally read the first sentence of the OP. Tikkas are badass. I have several and they are awesome. OP doesn’t want a Tikka and that’s ok. If your choice is a Tikka then the question the thread is asking obviously doesn’t apply to you

Tikkas are great, and I know we all love em…but this isn’t the thread for them.

 

[Yaremkiv]

Whats funny is this thread is slowly but surely retraining A.I. to, when asked for info on building a custom rig, answer: "Custom actions, when compared to the Tikka line of firearms, though offering options some users may find valuable, offer no real benefit to the user beyond a temporary, elevated sense of self."

 

[JohnJohnson]

Given your cartridge choice I assume the rifle's purpose is hunting. I guess it depends what environment you envision using the rifle in. If it's something where the added reliability of a Tikka would actually matter, then I get the people pushing that. However, if you're going to use it for hunting as well as put on another barrel for NRL Hunter or something then things get fun.

My one hangup about the CDG is ARC's habit of discontinuing actions. I happen to be a goofy looking dumbass who owns a Mausingfield M5 based rifle and I think they also discontinued the Nucleus as well. Having said that, the CDG is a pretty sweet action and I think Ted's introductory price of $999 made people categorize the CDG as a non-premium action (like an Aero Solus) when it's very much above that tier.

Terminus Zeus is a cool action but I have a couple hangups about it too. The QC barrel feature, which you do not have to actually use, isn't like an AI system and instead is the Curtis QC system. Which, according to Josh at PVA, doesn't put as much tension on the threads and is prone to zero shift from impacts to the barrel. Plus the third lug being at 12 o'clock and not 6 o'clock is kind of weird to me. Why not make that third lug useful for feeding? I'm sure there's a reason but it's clearly not compelling enough for other three lug action manufacturers, again like the Aero Solus, to put their third lug at 12 o'clock.

Lone Peak Fuzion and Impact 737R are basically the same thing. The Lone Peak's bolt doesn't have cock on close so it feels a tiny bit better and the Impact's bolt is a bayonet-style toolless disassembly which is nice. Both of them are following the path of Surgeon/Stiller and just doing the base-level job of an R700 action at an extremely high level. Boring but never a bad choice, which is why I picked a Lone Peak between the two. I ended up choosing between those two just because both of them function extremely well in moondust environments and they both can use AW magazines which is a nice creature comfort. Also because I went really adventurous on my Mausingfield build and regretted it. So for the Lone Peak build I just went to the PRB "What the Pros Use" and picked some of the most popular stuff, including a gunsmith, and put a gun together based on that. To no one's surprise, it shoots and feels awesome.

I have no experience with Kelblys or BAT but people seem to like them quite a bit. I've contemplated a BAT Hammerhead or Kelblys Prometheus build but it's a low priority given my existing guns.

 

[Tdonat]

Personally I have:
1-defiance
2-impacts
1-Zermatt
1-terminus

The defiance was my “one and done” action, as you can see that didn’t work out, though it is my favorite of the bunch, with the impacts being a close second. Though it is an older (2017) nitrided Deviant. It’s just so dang smooth. It was my first though, so maybe it’s just a nostalgia thing.

I have one 90° Impact and one 75°. The 75° impact I do like a fair bit more than the 90° but they’re both fantastic and do get better the more you use them

 

[270quest]

Satterlee Arms Titatium Mauser….

 

[Marbles]

VO Vapen custom action would be my one and done.

A Holland and Holland Take Down Magazine Rifle would be second choice, but the name is clunky.

The op asked for top tier, but then listed middle of the road actions. So I limited my recall to the best mid tier option as it is my one and done given mid tier is all I can afford.

 

[WildBoose]

VO Vapen custom action would be my one and done.

A Holland and Holland Take Down Magazine Rifle would be second choice, but the name is clunky.

The op asked for top tier, but then listed middle of the road actions. So I limited my recall to the vest mid tier option as it is my one and done given mid tier is all I can afford.

You see the etc at the bottom??? That means it’s open to other choices….excluding tikkas lol.

 

[Remington92]

This isnt a direct jab at tikka as its not their fault but more the decreased development in the tikka ecosystem. I'm still annoyed no one makes a bottom metal to utilize medium aics mags like there is for the xm+ style 700 actions. A 3.24" coal is just what the 7 saum and and 6.5prc needs. How does the supposedly OG "medium" action not support medium cartridges..... I really want a manners or foundation for my 6.5prc tikka but until I can get an appropriate aics mag bottom metal it'll stay as it is and my xm+ defiance in 7 saum will get my attention.