NeoAir Xlite VS> Xtherm

[HUNT JR]

Looking at these two pads, the weight difference is negligible, but what I am really looking at from you guys is for those who have ran both, is there a noticeable warmth difference?

I may backpack into November with it with a hot tent, is the xtherm going to be the way to go?

 

[Desk Jockey]

I have an older neo air. Very noisy. Crinkles. Enough that may camp mates notice from 10 feet away. I prefer my xtherm more but moved onto a sea to summit pad

 

[Turkeygetpwnd38]

I have both, xlite for early season and x therm for late. There isn’t a wrong answer. If I could only have one, I’d go xlite. Whatever you do go wide. Even if you aren’t a big guy, that extra width is nice.

 

[IdahoHunter57]

xtherm is a damn nice pad. Got it because of the higher R value compared to my Nemo tensor insulated. But I would sacrifice the Lil R value and gain it in comfort going with the Nemo.

 

[stephane110]

I don’t have experience with both, as I only have the xtherm. But I did a bunch of research when deciding to get it, and I figure it’s the perfect “do everything” pad. Tough to find one with a higher R value, fairly comfortable, pretty lightweight, AND it has 70D bottom fabric so I feel a little more confident that I wont poke a hole in it. A lot of the other ones I was considering like the xlite and the tensor only have 20D bottom fabric.
I’ve used my xtherm around 30 nights and love it.

 

[5MilesBack]

I tried the X-lite and didn't like it. It was loud, but also wasn't very warm at all. I got cold on it in July in the high country with a 0 degree quilt. Then got the Xtherm, haven't had any issues since.

 

[mlgc20]

I have both. Yes, there is a difference in warmth. Both are great. But, the Xtherm is a true 4 season pad. Never had any issue using the Xlite for its intended 3 season use. But, I wouldn't take it throw it down on the snow in single digit weather like I have the Xtherm.

 

[StopMakingSense]

I run both and use the XTherm when I know I want to bring my 0 bag

If I could only pick one it would be the XTherm

 

[PVS]

My Xlite starts feeling cool around the low 30's. That is fully inflated in a bridge hammock. I have been interested in the Xtherms, but have not tried one yet.

 

[TristanJH]

There is definitely a perceptible difference in the R-value - Enough that I dislike using the x-therm in the summer and strongly prefer the x-therm in later seasons, specifically when there is any chance that overnight lows dip below 30F.

 

[Dos Perros]

If you're a little feller like me, the X-lite Women's has a higher R-value than the regular X-lite, and is still pretty light.

 

[HUNT JR]

I ended up going with the X-Therm I would rather be a little overkill and stay warmer and for the weight difference, it seemed like a no brainer to me.

Thanks for the help!

 

[Weber]

I did the same and I have 0 regrets. It weighs practically nothing more.

 

[Dos Perros]

FYI the crinkle on these pads goes away after a bit with some use.