I like the Heathers Choice meals, but have found that they don't appeal to everyone. Some of this may have with how you are used to eating. They are intentionally high in fat, so if you aren't used to a diet of high fat/ grain free, then they may not suit your palate at all. I've read that a lot of people can't get past the beef gelatin in the breakfast meals. It tastes fine to me, in fact I really like the breakfast meals. The HC meals are certainly closer to the types of meals that I eat at home than any of the MH offerings.
I agree with all of this. I've liked all but one of the HC dinners and really enjoy the breakfasts and packaroons. Her food most closely mirrors what I eat at home. I could see where someone with a diet with sugar in it with some regularity would not enjoy the breakfasts, they are not at all sweet, but I really enjoy them. I also like how nutritionally dense her food is, way more so than mountain house.