Knives: money money or not

Sharpening isn't the grand myth it's often made out to be. The issue seems to be that there are so many ways to achieve the end result. This makes the real challenge trying different methods until you find the one that suits you personally. There are a couple of ways I just don't do well, but a couple others I can really nail.

Eww tubes is your friend in this arena.
 
I've never seen a Chinese steel knife blade that will resharpen to shaving sharp. So they're not even an option from the start.
I have a few Chinese made edc folders in D2 that not only get hair popping sharp but also hold a good edge for much longer than many USA made knives within the same rough price range. I agree most are no good though
 
I've never seen a Chinese steel knife blade that will resharpen to shaving sharp. So they're not even an option from the start.
Spydercos do, but they don't retain that sharpness very long. Life is too short for for those steels in my opinion though and they aren't an option for me either. Especially when there are much, much better options for not much more $.
 
I agree. I like the"super" steels. Touch them up regularly and you don't need to spend hours sharpening them.
Spydercos do, but they don't retain that sharpness very long. Life is too short for for those steels in my opinion though and they aren't an option for me either. Especially when there are much, much better options for not much more $.
To many good and great steel's now available to waste time with inferior products.
 
I have followed this to a tee for the last decade since I saw a havalon in use🤙 That being said this knife is cool looking and looks sell 🤣💯
Personally, I carry a fixed 4" blade S30V steel knife that I paid $30 for, and a Havalon that I also paid $30 for. I use the Havalon for skinning and caping, and the fixed blade mostly for everything else. I just try to keep everything as clean as possible. The S30V knife is still very sharp after a bull elk, and the Havalon gets a new blade for the next one.
 

Attachments

  • 2B1503A2-37FE-4C94-8675-9AEA321448E5.png
    2B1503A2-37FE-4C94-8675-9AEA321448E5.png
    1.1 MB · Views: 32
I'll bite.. I'm a knife nut as well as a gun nut... for me it's about finding something that doesnt just work but that works WELL.. I have AO in my hands and chronic tendonitis in my forearms from my career.. a poorly designed knife is so much harder to use as it requires different hand / wrist angles as well as just not being designed to utilize the full length of the blade... the more though put into grip ergos, blade ergos, grip to blade ergos, grind ect the better the knife will perform. Look at a mora for instance...great knife that will do the job, but its ergos are designed for bush craft not skinning. Most of the blade isn't even used while gutting or skinning because its designed for a different task. Other things like heat treat, steel type, play a big roll in higher priced knives as well.. I have no interest in wasting time sharpening when I should be disassembling a downed elk. Nor do I want to carry two knives if I can only cay one..
I liken it to axes. A cheap department store axe will chop a tree down. But a well designed properly built axe with detail taken to the overall design of what makes an axe chop well does the same job in way less time with way less effort. Until you use top notch gear it's hard to understand why a guy would spend $200 dollars on an axe when a $50 dollar axe will cut too unless your only ever going to cut one tree down...same as a knife until you use a well though out design made by a skilled craftsman built specifically for the task your trying to do, you'll be more than satisfied with a bargain knife especially if you dont use it a ton or often.. at the end of the day a broken bottle will gut, skin, and part out any deer ever born...most guys would rather use a knife.
As I 90% of the time do gutless for my use a knife has to "unzip" a hide, skin, and part out/ debone as well as not wear my hands arms out in the process as well as hold an edge for the whole duration of the job. I've never found a "cheap" knife meet those parameters.
Well on that note, what knives do you have and like!? Im a bit of a knife nut myself!
 
Well on that note, what knives do you have and like!? Im a bit of a knife nut myself!
I went with a full custom made by a somewhat local builder here in Alberta. As I do gutless 90% of the time the knife is designed solely around those tasks. It's a semi skinner type with my own preferences. I had it made in magnacut with a really nice high hollow grind. The grip is 100% custom and shaped to fit my hand/ grip perfectly to reduce hand and arm fatigue while using it. ( with OA in my hands this is a big issue for me) As such it might not fit the next guy well but hey it's my knife! Lol I'm hoping to have a boning knife and a bird and trout made with similar attention to details given to the particular tasks they will be required to do.
 
For 35 years, I used cheap knives, largely because I couldn’t sharpen worth a tinker’s damn. Then Havalon’s came out and I thought I’d never need anything else until I was on a bitter cold moose hunt on the Canadian prairies, with the wind howling. Buddy shot a nice big cow moose. Pulled out my Havalon and went to work, only to find the fat freezing onto, and gumming up the blade of the Havalon, rendering it pretty much useless. My buddy handed me his custom knife. A simple 3.5” drop point with CPM154 steel, sharpened very well which made processing that moose a breeze. Eureka. This is what I was missing. Learned how to sharpen really well, and ordered a nice custom shortly after. Now I am a knife nut, and also and advocate of well made custom knives as giving a wonderful return on investment. Don’t get me wrong, nothing wrong with a nice factory hunting knife made from quality materials. I have sharpened many Benchmades for buddies that fall into that category, and will do a fantastic job. But if you need a custom like Obsessed1 or want a custom just because, there is no way to itch that scratch rather than just jumping and getting one. I find the planning of and choosing the materials and exact design to be such a fun part of the process. And I end up with something I just take out many times throughout the year and enjoy the craftsmanship of it. That is worth something to me.

I also think the disposable blades are so popular because not many guys are actually good at sharpening knives. Just an observation.
 
A knife is a tool and can serve a lot of purposes besides working on an animal. You probably should think thru all the functions you might need your knife to perform and decide what’s best for your next hunt and future adventures.
 
I recommend whatever you choose, go with bright orange handle so you can find it when you put it down in the dark/thick brush.
I agree with the orange handle. My buddy had his brand new Benchmade knife get pulled out of the case in thick brush. We used his InReach track to backtrack the next day and I noticed it sitting in the brush in the picture I attached. He was so thankful for that impossible find. I use simple Outdoor Edge knives with orange handles.

IMG_8589 Medium.jpegIMG_8617 Medium.jpeg
 
I once gutted and boned out a buck with a $10.00 butterfly knife when I was in 18 or 19. I remember having a difficult time toward the end. Didnt have a pack but was carrying plastic garbage bags and used those to pack it out.

I now have a nice pack with a shelf and carry a few moderately expensive benchmade hunt knives.

I prefer a fixed blade I can sharpen. If you have the money my vote is for a nice knife that can potentially last you a lifetime. Maybe even hand it down to family or friends. It may sound dumb but I can look at my knife and remember its history and brings me back to some of my memorable hunts over the years.

Havalon or an old timer $20 fixed blade special will get the job done just the same. If you ever lose it, you probably won't spend hours looking for it in the woods.
 
Back
Top