GRITTY - FILM PERMITS - YOUR THOUGHTS?

[archp625]

I'm in the process of listening to his podcast that came out today. I know my thoughts, what are yours?

 

[cuerro viejo]

Rules are Rules even if dumb and outdated.

don’t like the campaign to turn them over

 

[307]

I can't listen to Brian. Care to offer a brief synopsis?

 

[archp625]

I can't listen to Brian. Care to offer a brief synopsis?

I can give my point of view. He basically got in trouble for filming hunts without a film permit. They showed up at his house. They gave him a ticket because he was not there for 3 weeks. He was pissed because he knew the rules and basically his brand got bigger and he never got the permits. So he basically pled that he was innocent by ignorance.

Then he proceed to get made because the feds make it so hard to get a film permit and bitched about the method. Had a guy on there agree to what he was saying. Then I turned it off.

I wish at my job we could not get permits then have employees get pulled over and get pissed and just act like we didn't know.

 

[archp625]

Rules are Rules even if dumb and outdated.

don’t like the campaign to turn them over

I agree. Randy gets permits and the other people that do not hunt private. Randy seems to handle the permits just fine. I think I am more annoyed how he did not really want to own up to it and basically wanted to make excuses.

 

[qwerksc]

Not hard to comment on this...Pleads "Naive American"

 

[jt4]

I can give my point of view. He basically got in trouble for filming hunts without a film permit. They showed up at his house. They gave him a ticket because he was not there for 3 weeks. he was pissed because he knew the rules and basically his brand got bigger and he never got the permits. So he basically pled that he was innocent by ignorance.

Then he proceed to get made because the feds make it so hard to get a film permit and bitched about the method. Had a guy on there agree to what he was saying. Then I turned it off.

I wish at my job we could not get permits then have employees get pulled over and get pissed at just act like we didn't know.

Little devils advocate here....I skimmed through a video where he mentioned it. I don’t think he acted like he didn’t know. Seems like he admits he knew the law and just said F it.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

 

[rclouse79]

If the bear hunts with Lampers were some of the illegally shot videos I will have to admit to partaking of the forbidden fruit. Some of those episodes are pretty epic.

 

[KChunter71]

When Aaron left and started his own podcast I stopped listening to Mr Call not long after.

 

[P Carter]

Didn’t listen to the podcast, but I think there’s a strong argument that the requirement to get a film permit is unconstitutional. You don’t need a license to film in America. I’d love to see that tested.
Edit: I see that at least one court agrees, https://www.eenews.net/assets/2021/01/26/document_gw_01.pdf

 

[Cameron.25]

I will admit, his podcast i dont listen to much since snyder left but his bear films are pretty legit. I actually agree with him on somewhat, tho he is definately being a bit of a baby about it and i think he should just put that elk hunt in dispute out and not monotize it if thats an option. We probably have some outdated laws that could use some updating. Im sure these laws were aimed at more major productions when they were written that actually would negatively impact things since everyone didn't have cameras back then. Just because you make money off content doesn't necessarily mean you're negatively impacting the wilderness any more than the average joe that doesn't record it. Where do you draw the line tho? Could be a can of worms lol

 

[Dos Perros]

Permits for the commercialization of our public lands should be necessary, but they shouldn’t be discouragingly expensive or onerous to procure.

 

[def90]

There was a legal ruling on commercial filming in national parks just a few days ago. The judge ruled that filming is protected under the 1st amendment and that requiring and charging for permits is unconstitutional.

Judge: Commercial Filmmakers Don't Need Permits In National Parks

A federal judge has struck down as unconstitutional the National Park Service's practice of charging commercial filmmakers who want to shoot in the National Park System, ruling it is a protected activity under the First Amendment.

www.nationalparkstraveler.org

 

[jlaner0408]

Nothing like using ignorance for the law as a defense- seems to be pretty popular these days with the likes of gritty, Bowmar, Sterling, etc.

 

[ttucci16]

I'm a big fan of Brians films. He breaks down the issue pretty well in his podcast. I have to agree with Brian when he points out that the law is not enforced evenly across the board. They typically go after the guys who have really good content (His words, not mine). We have an entire outdoor industry and to think that a permit should be required in order to film and make money off of the permit seems a little overbearing and unamerican to me. I hope to see more of his films soon.

 

[full choke]

I am not much of a podcast guy. Don't even really know much about Brian Call. I have seen a few threads on here concerning him.
That seems to be a thing. If there are numerous threads over the years concerning your behavior- then maybe there is an issue?...

 

[25orSo]

There was a legal ruling on commercial filming in national parks just a few days ago. The judge ruled that filming is protected under the 1st amendment and that requiring and charging for permits is unconstitutional.

Judge: Commercial Filmmakers Don't Need Permits In National Parks

A federal judge has struck down as unconstitutional the National Park Service's practice of charging commercial filmmakers who want to shoot in the National Park System, ruling it is a protected activity under the First Amendment.

www.nationalparkstraveler.org

It sure would be nice to apply that ruling to the 2nd Amendment and not have to pay for a permit to bear arms........

 

[25orSo]

There was a legal ruling on commercial filming in national parks just a few days ago. The judge ruled that filming is protected under the 1st amendment and that requiring and charging for permits is unconstitutional.

Judge: Commercial Filmmakers Don't Need Permits In National Parks

A federal judge has struck down as unconstitutional the National Park Service's practice of charging commercial filmmakers who want to shoot in the National Park System, ruling it is a protected activity under the First Amendment.

www.nationalparkstraveler.org

It sure would be nice to apply that ruling to the 2nd Amendment and not have to pay for a permit to bear arms........

 

[TheTone]

His first post on the subject was that he knew of the permits, but said his filming wasn’t commercial. If his filming isn’t commercial then what is he doing for a job? It’s fully a component of his “business “. I’m not about to give him a listen to hear his thoughts on it

 

[Jon Boy]

Id love to hear peoples opinion that are in defense of him, how they would feel if outfitters didn't have to pay for permits to guide hunts on public land? Id even wager a bet that these YouTube douchers that aren't pulling permits are making more net income than outfitters. All the while blowing the living shit out of public land and selling out every chance they get. Calls a freaking puppet that would suck a golf ball through a garden hose for another sponsor. And guys like call, born and raised, and hushin are all exploiting public land for profit and making full time livings at it while not pulling permits. Newbergs been doing it for years so dont give me so poor me wo me bull shit. Sure wish I didn't have to have licenses and permits for my job.

Sent from my SM-G965U using Tapatalk