First Wolf Kill of Livestock in Colorado

sasquatch

WKR
Joined
Jul 26, 2015
Messages
955
This negative feedback loop will escalate quickly. Wolves eat elk > elk population declines > less elk means fewer hunters > less tag revenue for CPW + wolves eat livestock > CPW has to reimburse ranchers.

Revenue goes down and expenses go up.

Three decades from now, the kids of these urban yuppies who voted for wolf reintroduction will be trying to figure out how to save the elk without killing wolves or raising revenue from hunting.

Easy to fix

Take names of who voted for the s***.

Those people get extra charge on their property taxes. A good old pay for what you want scenario.

If they rent, we’ll then we will deal with it on the income tax side.

If they don’t work, we deduct it from their welfare.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
 

sasquatch

WKR
Joined
Jul 26, 2015
Messages
955
Wait, so you're telling me that dogs dont kill more livestock in states that actually have wolves in them? Crazy.

Also, there are approximately 90 million dogs in the US compared to 18,000 estimated wolves, no $h!t they kill more livestock nationally. Just more Buzz statistics at work.

How many of those fluffies you think kill elk/deer/moose? Lol


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
 

fatlander

WKR
Joined
Feb 11, 2016
Messages
2,159
And actually interpret the data.

Overall dogs kill more. In states that have wolves, it's not even close, wolves kill far more than dogs. If there were wolves in 50 states the overall numbers wouldn't be close.

Most all the Dog deaths are in the southeast. There are virtually none in wolf states.

And how may have the data changed since the study was done? 6 years is a long time and a lot of missing data.

Sent from my moto g power using Tapatalk

Exactly.

You’re overwhelmingly not likely to be attacked by a shark. But if you’re swimming in the mangroves at midnight, you may have a slightly better chance than a guy that lives in Nebraska.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Joined
Jul 17, 2017
Messages
722
Domestic dogs kill wayyyyy more livestock than wolves....fact.

Keep fluffy on a leash if you're concerned about cattle loss.
Who is trying to introduce more domestic dogs? Seems to be a bit of a red herring to divert the discussion from wolves to domestic dogs. Are you saying cattle loss is not a valid concern with wolf reintroduction? Do you support wolf reintroduction in Colorado? Since you fashion yourself a follower of science, do you endorse ballot box biology in places like Colorado?
 

Trap

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
Dec 18, 2021
Messages
213
You should worry more about lions than wolves.
Not where I live in Idaho. I’m a long time hound hunter and I actually feel we should lessen our take of lions. 2 cat areas and hound seasons run till end of June. That’s too much pressure on lions. In the 90’s it was easy to cut a lion track to run that’s not the case anymore. Funny thing is I found way more bears and lions in the 90’s and the elk herds were as good as I can ever remember. Today I observe way less cats and bears but way less elk. What’s the X factor? I see and have seen way more wolve tracks for last 15 years while looking for lions. I saw and read the idfg report showing lions in Cda river taking more elk. Frankly it’s not very believable since 90 percent of the lion kills I have found have been deer. That’s decades of on the ground observation. I can only say in my pocket of Idaho the elk decline happened after WOLVES showed up in larger numbers.
 

WCB

WKR
Joined
Jun 12, 2019
Messages
3,642
I live in FL and have never understood why they would re-introduce a predator unless there were an overabundance of a specific species (i.e. deer in a state that has a lot of deer strikes while driving). To me it's like a solution looking for a problem.

From my point of view (down here in sunny SW FL) were it a wolf preying on my cattle, I would shoot it and drop it off at the Train Station - or a 6' hole and apply the castle doctrine.
NO problem with reintroduction really...There just has to be an actual end date and plan for management. Once they are met game on. The way it gets tied up in court is total B.S. after management objectives are blown out of the water. CO will have zero intent to properly manage...look at the Black Bear population. Now imagine that with the polarization of wolves
 

RMM

WKR
Joined
Jan 30, 2021
Messages
403
Location
PA
How many of those fluffies you think kill elk/deer/moose? Lol


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
I know it happens, more so with deer than elk or moose. I would still wager wolves kill more nationally that domestic dogs.
 
Joined
Sep 20, 2018
Messages
7,571
Location
In someone's favorite spot
I live in FL and have never understood why they would re-introduce a predator unless there were an overabundance of a specific species (i.e. deer in a state that has a lot of deer strikes while driving). To me it's like a solution looking for a problem.

From my point of view (down here in sunny SW FL) were it a wolf preying on my cattle, I would shoot it and drop it off at the Train Station - or a 6' hole and apply the castle doctrine.
Here you go -


3. CPW has intentionally reduced elk populations to achieve population objectives set for each herd. Currently, 22 of 42 (52%) elk herds are still above their current population objective ranges (Table 2).

This information isn't hard to find but it won't change the minds of any individual who his hell bent on blaming wolves for everything under the sun.
 

Gerbdog

WKR
Joined
Jun 8, 2020
Messages
911
Location
CO Springs
So... the way i understand it (i rarely have enough facts and data to make anything understandable to me, so dont shoot me), the farmers arent happy with the elk destroying their crops... so they want the herds reduced.... why introduce wolves ? Just let hunters take another elk each season in the 52% over populated herds? Wolves just tick off the ranchers / farmers and the elk will probably still eat their crops (easy, nutritious food).

My guess is this had nothing to do with CPW and more to do with the fact that wolves somehow ended up on the ballot and won by ... whatever, 0.5%.

Ah well, glass half full, maybe one day there will be a wolf hunting season i can partake in, i suspect my chances of getting a moose hunt will decline drastically.... may as well stop putting in for those points....
 

kentuckybowman

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
Jun 12, 2020
Messages
216
It’s only fair that the people of eastern Colorado be exposed to the same wolf threat they have imposed on the people of western Colorado. Then they will have a quick attitude adjustment as packs run through Arvada and Boulder.
 
Joined
Sep 20, 2018
Messages
7,571
Location
In someone's favorite spot
I'm always curious about the motivation of anti-wolf hunters. On the surface it sure seems like folks who so vocally opposed to wolves are simply worried about not having enough critters to shoot. Is that it? If having wolves in the landscape was actually better for the ecosystem (not saying it is, but if it is) would everyone here still feel the same way or would we all still hate wolves because they compete with us for game? Are we really that selfish? I guess that's what I'm trying to figure out when I see so many hunters spew hate about wolves thread after thread after thread...

Or is it the ranchers we're worried about? You know, the same ones who lock us out of our public lands. A person really needs a scorecard to keep up with the logic here.
 

Gerbdog

WKR
Joined
Jun 8, 2020
Messages
911
Location
CO Springs
I'm always curious about the motivation of anti-wolf hunters. On the surface it sure seems like folks who so vocally opposed to wolves are simply worried about not having enough critters to shoot. Is that it? If having wolves in the landscape was actually better for the ecosystem (not saying it is, but if it is) would everyone here still feel the same way or would we all still hate wolves because they compete with us for game? Are we really that selfish? I guess that's what I'm trying to figure out when I see so many hunters spew hate about wolves thread after thread after thread...

Or is it the ranchers we're worried about? You know, the same ones who lock us out of our public lands. A person really needs a scorecard to keep up with the logic here.
I can unequivocally say... for myself... yup! im a selfish hunter. I had a long debate with myself when i voted on the subject... sure i think it might be cool to see a pack of wolves when im out hunting... sure i get that they have a place in the ecosystem.... all of that.... and then at the end of the day i decided i was a selfish hunter. Ashamed? nah. I get both sides of the argument and at the end of the day i just voted for number 1 in my world. I'll just learn to hunt with the wolves and find the elk since it didnt go my way, heck maybe ill run across a pack and decide it was the best experience ive ever had.... trying to be optimistic.
 
Joined
Sep 20, 2018
Messages
7,571
Location
In someone's favorite spot
I can unequivocally say... for myself... yup! im a selfish hunter. I had a long debate with myself when i voted on the subject... sure i think it might be cool to see a pack of wolves when im out hunting... sure i get that they have a place in the ecosystem.... all of that.... and then at the end of the day i decided i was a selfish hunter. Ashamed? nah. I get both sides of the argument and at the end of the day i just voted for number 1 in my world. I'll just learn to hunt with the wolves and find the elk since it didnt go my way, heck maybe ill run across a pack and decide it was the best experience ive ever had.... trying to be optimistic.
I appreciate that honest answer. Nothing wrong with that IMO.
 

Trap

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
Dec 18, 2021
Messages
213
State agencies manage wolves too.
Or mismanage them. How is Washington and Oregon doing with wolf management? The term management varies greatly with the politics of each state. Look up Washington wolf plan and tell me how are they managing wolves? They need more wolves and so called breeding pairs than wy, Mt, id combined before they can even think about hunter management of wolves. I can see this exact scenario play out in Colorado with the abundance of what I would call greenies moving in or already there.
 
Top