I've worn a pair of Meindl Hunters the last 3 years and I am very pleased with them. Love the fit of the boot, wide toe box, but would like a little more ankle support. With lots of boulder crossing and side hilling this past year, my ankles seemed really fatigued and sore at the end of each day.
Here is what I would like in a elk hunting boot:
Under 4lbs. - we put a lot of miles on each day
Full rand - at times we are in some pretty tough, rocky area
Must be waterproof! - very wet wear I hunt, lot of springs, marshes, small creeks.
Good Ankle support - lots of rocky areas and boulder field crossings
Good lacing system - moving all day, expect a boot to stay in place all day.
Under $400 - can't justify paying outrageous price for boots I will only be wearing 8 days out of the year.
That being said I have the following boots on my watch list so far:
Lowa Tibet GTX
Lowa Cevedale GTX
Scarpa Revolution Plus GTX
Scarpa Revolution Trek GTX
Meindl Denali