Does everyone that kills a 190 class buck just round up to 200”?

[thisguy]

I'm guessing a lot of hunters don't actually score their critters or even know how to properly do it. Theres guys who swear up and down to a certain number but you can see plain as day its 10-20" smaller. Around here its whitetail hunters who claim 160s that are solidly in the 140s. Maybe they know how to score but are generous on rounding up. At the end of the day its all just an anatomy measuring contest anyway

To answer the OPs question, I'd call a lower 190s buck 190 but if it was upper 190s I'd probably round up to 200 too. Although thats a situation I'll probably never be in

 

[ianpadron]

Ya all I know is that the older I get the less I care.

200 is gigantic, but to me a 170” typical with heavy forks and sweet bases is a deer that I will proudly hang my tag on. Especially when I watch him lose velvet and figure out his routine.

I think I would honestly rather shoot a 180” buck I have history with then a 200” buck I just stumble into first day of season on an out of state hunt.

Huntings reward is so much more than inches.

The day I let a dark heavy 170 walk is the day I hang things up for good.

 

[huntnful]

The day I let a dark heavy 170 walk is the day I hang things up for good.

I killed a 6.5 year old, dark horned, 2” eyeguard, almost perfectly symmetrical 30” wide, 178” gross buck and he’s an absolute specimen of a muley. I’ll be happy to kill a buck like that every year for the rest of my life.

 

[ianpadron]

I killed a 6.5 year old, dark horned, 2” eyeguard, almost perfectly symmetrical 30” wide, 178” gross buck and he’s an absolute specimen of a muley. I’ll be happy to kill a buck like that every year for the rest of my life.

Yessir I can picture the exact type of buck you're describing.

The textbook prototype for sure. I'll never get tired of the quick surge of adrenaline when that class of deer walks out of the timber after their younger herd mates.

 

[huntnful]

167”
169”
178”


Be a shame to lie about these deer. I think the general public should know that a 170 class muley is a legit buck, and 190”+ is truly next level.

 

[littlebigtine]

167”
169”
178”
View attachment 1021664

Be a shame to lie about these deer. I think the general public should know that a 170 class muley is a legit buck, and 190”+ is truly next level.

Is it just the angle or is the head on that bottom buck huge?

 

[svivian]

Just go to the mule deer meat pole thread to see plenty of nose down, rack pushed out, long arm pics trying to make bucks bigger than they are.

Sad thing is some of them are pretty nice bucks but just makes them look silly.

 

[huntnful]

Is it just the angle or is the head on that bottom buck huge?

No that head is absolutely giant. I point it to out everyone that comes over lol. It’s probably 20% bigger than any deer skull I have in the house. The body was also giant. He was 26.5” ear tip to ear tip.

 

[littlebigtine]

No that head is absolutely giant. I point it to out everyone that comes over lol. It’s probably 20% bigger than any deer skull I have in the house. The body was also giant. He was 26.5” ear tip to ear tip.

Damn thats a spread for sure. Was he tough to field judge? Probably did the opposite of ground shrinkage walking up to him..

 

[pirogue]

So this one was 191. You’re saying I can just round up to 200?

 

[Andrew12gauge]

The day I let a dark heavy 170 walk is the day I hang things up for good.

I struggle with letting 150-160” bucks walk. I usually don’t have the time to commit to finding those next level bucks and I’m plenty tickled with that size of bucks.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[huntnful]

Damn thats a spread for sure. Was he tough to field judge? Probably did the opposite of ground shrinkage walking up to him..

Absolutely. I watched him for a few minutes under 400 yards. He was with another really nice buck. So I was going back and forth looking them over. I thought he was going to be about 27-28” and 170” when I killed him.

He ended up being 30” and 178”. I knew right when I walked up on him that he was bigger than I thought.

I have great video of him beforehand and he is hard to judge. You wouldn’t think he was 30” honestly.

 

[littlebigtine]

Absolutely. I watched him for a few minutes under 400 yards. He was with another really nice buck. So I was going back and forth looking them over. I thought he was going to be about 27-28” and 170” when I killed him.

He ended up being 30” and 178”. I knew right when I walked up on him that he was bigger than I thought.

I have great video of him beforehand and he is hard to judge. You wouldn’t think he was 30” honestly.

View attachment 1022355
View attachment 1022356

Woah thats a tank. Curious what state? I mostly hunt Idaho and the biggest ear spread ive seen is 23”.

 

[robby denning]

167”
169”
178”
View attachment 1021664

Be a shame to lie about these deer. I think the general public should know that a 170 class muley is a legit buck, and 190”+ is truly next level.

all sweet bucks!!!!!!

 

[huntnful]

all sweet bucks!!!!!!

I'm super happy with them!!

 

[RockAndSage]

Absolutely. I watched him for a few minutes under 400 yards. He was with another really nice buck. So I was going back and forth looking them over. I thought he was going to be about 27-28” and 170” when I killed him.

He ended up being 30” and 178”. I knew right when I walked up on him that he was bigger than I thought.

I have great video of him beforehand and he is hard to judge. You wouldn’t think he was 30” honestly.

View attachment 1022355
View attachment 1022356

Man, what a beautiful buck...

 

[Mtncowboy]

One point of defense for the expo, is the location- the high ceilings and open spaces do make the trophies look smaller than a normal setting in a house etc.


This is why I generally support scoring organizations like B&C and P&Y- they do provide credibility when animals are officially entered!!

On a side note I killed a whitetail that net 198.5” non-typical, (was 206” gross) official P&Y with a broken G2….

Does that qualify as a 200”er??

That's incredible! Please post a picture of that buck. Dream deer!