DIY RokStok in maple

OP
Mtnmilsurp
Joined
Dec 16, 2021
Messages
607
Location
Larkspur, CO
For OP or anyone who knows, would a laminated piece of wood with alternating grain direction be more rigid and/or better? I'm certain it wouldn't be more attractive...

I have no experience with laminate but expect it would be more of a challenge to inlet precisely by hand. You’d constantly be running into glue and differing wood grain and density, no?
 

Macintosh

WKR
Joined
Feb 17, 2018
Messages
2,750
For OP or anyone who knows, would a laminated piece of wood with alternating grain direction be more rigid and/or better? I'm certain it wouldn't be more attractive...
More rigid, maybe a little, but not enough to matter.
Laminate will change less dimensionally compared to some wood…but a good air-dried eu walnut blank that is well sealed changes very little dimensionally. Probably not enough to matter for 99.9% of the people out there.
Strength…perhaps significant depending on the shape of the stock. The reason you dont see a lot of vertical-grip wood stocks is that its much, much harder to lay out the stock on a wood blank so the grain doesnt cross the wrist, which creates a major (and potentially catastrophic) weak point. For a VG stock a laminate of some sort might be a better choice for this reason. I believe the wood rockstock that will be commercially available is done as a sort of laminate—not lots of thin layers, but a inner layer with the two nice-looking slabs of wood on the outside. I highly suspect this is simply due to the grain runout in the wrist. Ive been toying with a build like this and would certainly be picky about the blank and might also set a couple pieces of threaded rod or a good-sized dowel in the wrist to avoid this issue.
“Better” is very subjective. Laminate is closer to a synthetic…ie lower maintenence, lower initial cost, etc. But laminate is generally heavier, may be harder to work on with hand tools, and short of a specialty layup like above doesn't look nearly as good. Depends on what you are after.
 
Last edited:
Top