Interesting as I used to feel as you do now. I would spend days going through the different tuning methods tweaking things and then always finish off with broadhead tuning. Once the bow was broadhead tuned, If I shot through paper, walk back, bare shaft etc it was always off with those others. If I changed things to get a good tear again then my broadhead tuning would be off and I would have to change that again. Felt like all I was doing was chasing my tail so started skipping most of the steps because it really wasn't doing me any good.
Then I took some shooting lessons. Over the last year I have had everything but my anchor point changed. Tuning a bow is easy, shooting a bow correctly and more importantly, consistently is very hard. IMO, the average bowhunter, which I would consider myself, can't shoot well or consistent enough to get much benefit from all of the super tuning methods. If you don't have proper and consistent form all of the tuning in the world won't help you. Prior to taking lessons you would have never convinced me of this nor would you have convinced me that I shot a bow very poorly.
Since I've taken the lessons and blind bale shooting for three months my tuning has changed quite a bit. I set the rest on center, set the arrow level and take out cam lean. I get a bullet hole and bare shafts group with FP's and I haven't needed to broadhead tune. If my BH's aren't with my FP's it is something I am doing not a tuning issue. I think far too much emphasis or blame is placed on tuning and not near enough on correct and consistent form. It isn't because of any tuning methods that it has gotten easier for me, purely a form and consistency issue. I still struggle with it every day.
I would love to hear Darin's thoughts on this as well. How I see it now is that you set a bow up correctly and anything you have to change from that point is detuning the bow or changing the bow to your specific form. Unless there is something wrong with a bow any of them will put an arrow in the same hole all day every day with a hooter shooter. When we get a hold of them all bets are off.