You are right, I was wrong in saying that bitcoins don't exist. Thank you, sincerely, it helps me clarify my thoughts.
Bitcoins do exist. However, they exist as ideas not as material. That difference has deep implications.
Start by thinking about the relationship between price and value.
If you want to know the price of gasoline, look at the gas station sign.
If you want to know the value of gasoline, fill up your tank, drive until you run out of gas, and push your vehicle back to the gas station.
Gasoline’s value is its molecular structure, which is combustible, and can move your car a long way.
The value of gasoline declines rapidly. It oxidizes, it gets contaminated and pretty soon it won't move your car. If you want to store gasoline, you have to add ingredients to slow its molecules’ degradation and that costs you something.
The value of gold, like gasoline (and all commodities) is its atomic structure, but there is something remarkable about gold’s atomic structure: gold does not oxidize. Apart from nuclear reactions within stars, gold atoms never change, react, or become part of other molecules with new sets of properties. Gold’s value doesn't change because its utility doesn't change because its structure doesn't change.
It is reasonable to trade an appropriate weight of gold for a can of gasoline if you need to mow your lawn. However, let that can of gasoline sit in the shop for five years and it would be unreasonable to trade even a tiny amount of gold to have it. This demonstrates that because gold’s atomic structure is incorruptible, its material value is constant. But all the other materials in the economy degrade over time. Therefore, gold measures the relative value of other materials, which is why it functions as money for economic materials.
Bitcoin does not have physical properties or uses. Its value is as an idea. Its price will not be determined by its attributes in the physical world, but by political ideas, movements and affinities. Consider the case of meme coins. The price of doge coin is moved by people's affinity for Elon Musk. The price of Elizabeth Warren coins is moved by people's hatred of her. Bitcoin's price is moved by people's confidence in the network of people that have it and use it. As I understand you, you value Bitcoin because you associate it with the idea of freedom you believe is embodied by the Bitcoin community interacting through the rigid rules of bitcoin's code.
Bitcoins, like political ideas and financial agreements, exist in the world of ideas and don't have stable price-relationships with things in the physical world.
For that reason I doubt Bitcoin will ever become a reliable pricing mechanism for materials-or function well as a currency. Its price will correlate with political relationships (political in the very broad sense of the intellectual dialogue and negotiation of human society). Bitcoin will compete very well against other ideas which derive their prices from polities: the dollar, the euro, etc. Bitcoin’s skyrocketing price is early evidence that people think the idea of Bitcoin is more valuable than the idea of dollars, but will it ever compete competently as a means to price commodities? Or will it be relegated like a meme coin to the momentum of crowds? We will all discover the answer to that question together day by day.
As a final word of caution about thinking simplistically, it is worth considering how the dollar's price relative to commodities has proven fairly stable. That is surprising and strange considering it is not a commodity and hasn't been redeemable for a commodity for decades. It isn't logical, but that is the unique power of ideas! They don't have to make sense. But eventually, reality reasserts itself. The dollar is finally progressing towards irrelevance, 60-100 years later than it logically should have. As the price of a dollar declines, its non-relationship to the natural world becomes more obvious. Today, March 23rd, the price of a dollar is
14.4mg Au. One day, the price of a dollar will probably be equal to its value: zero . . . or perhaps its price will be equal to the value of the cotton on which it is printed, which can be used as toilet paper or firestarter.