Ive had all of those knives at some point except the Serac.
In my kill kit is a Argali Col and Tyto Ti finisher. The Col is the skeletonized argali, and is quite a bit smaller than the carbon and serac, and even the Altitude. I keep the Col in my kill kit mostly because it weighs virtually nothing and takes up even less space. I would not take it as a primary fixed blade, but I think it could ultimately get the job done. Fixed blade skeleton knives are like communism, they sound great on paper. I dont think Ive ever used a skeletonized knife and didnt wish it had some kind of scales. At the same time, Ive never carried a fixed blade with scales that was so heavy that I wish it were skeletonized. The Saddle Mountain is pretty easily the heaviest out of that bunch. The altitude has a slightly different feel than most skeleton knives though because of that bit of scales at the front of the handle.
But the Steep Country (old version) will go with me wherever I go. The new version has grown on me a bit, but the old version is for me the alpha and omega. I did a pretty extensive write up on here between those 2.
I dont think you can go wrong with anything you listed though. You might end up going through all of them until you find the right one.
If I had to go with 1 fixed blade (I havent used the Serac):
1) Steep Country Original
2) Argali Carbon
3) Steep Country 2.0
4) Altitude
5) Saddle Mountain
In my kill kit is a Argali Col and Tyto Ti finisher. The Col is the skeletonized argali, and is quite a bit smaller than the carbon and serac, and even the Altitude. I keep the Col in my kill kit mostly because it weighs virtually nothing and takes up even less space. I would not take it as a primary fixed blade, but I think it could ultimately get the job done. Fixed blade skeleton knives are like communism, they sound great on paper. I dont think Ive ever used a skeletonized knife and didnt wish it had some kind of scales. At the same time, Ive never carried a fixed blade with scales that was so heavy that I wish it were skeletonized. The Saddle Mountain is pretty easily the heaviest out of that bunch. The altitude has a slightly different feel than most skeleton knives though because of that bit of scales at the front of the handle.
But the Steep Country (old version) will go with me wherever I go. The new version has grown on me a bit, but the old version is for me the alpha and omega. I did a pretty extensive write up on here between those 2.
I dont think you can go wrong with anything you listed though. You might end up going through all of them until you find the right one.
If I had to go with 1 fixed blade (I havent used the Serac):
1) Steep Country Original
2) Argali Carbon
3) Steep Country 2.0
4) Altitude
5) Saddle Mountain
Last edited: