I agree with you 100% that sheep hunting is often in "some of the most awesome country on the planet", but I definately wouldn't consider the Boone & Crockett Club as an "elitist bs club". Just like Ducks Unlimited or the Rocky Mountain Elk Foundation or a score other sportsmen's organizations, the B&C Club supports and works for wildlife conservation both politiclly and through on the ground projects. Anyone can join and you don't have to have killed a record book animal to become a member.
I killled my first deer, a spike muley buck, hunting with one of my college roommates. We enjoyed eating his venison that winter, and I proudly hung his spike antlers on my bedroom wall.
Like many big game hunters and just other people enjoy and are impressed with big horns and antlers. I bought my first B&C record book in 1973, and as a DIY public land hunter, I never thought that I would ever even see an animal that would qualify for their record book, let alone kill one.
Then in the late '70s I killed a big 6x6 bull elk on a DIY hunt on public land in NW Montana. I decided to have him mounted, and my taxidermist said that I should have him B&C scored. He gross scored the record book minimum, but symmetrical deductions kept him out.
In the early '80s I drew a Montana moose tag. Again, my DIY public land hunt in SW Montana yielded a very old, heavy, 50" Shiras bull moose. A great hunt, a freezer full of excellent moose burger, and every day I enjoy seeing his shoulder mount on my wall. But his antlers didn't meet the B&C scoring requirements.
The next year, my NW Montana hunting partner called and asked where he should apply for a moose tag. He put in for the same area where I had shot my bull, and drew a tag. We took my horses in, and first thing opening morning, we found a big bull moose. That bull met all of the B&C scoring requirements, and at that time, he was the 4th highest B&C scored moose from Montana. When my friend entered his moose with B&C, it is listed with my name as co-owner. Wow! My name is in the B&C Record Book.
In 2004 I booked a combination Caribou and Muskox hunt in the Arctic of Canada's Northwest Territory. There were 4 hunters in camp, and we all shot caribou bulls that qualified for the B&C Record Book, as did my Muskox bull. The B&C scorer that scored my bulls is a retired Montana FWP biologist that I've known for almost 50 years. My bulls were officially scored, but I didn't enter them for "the Book."
Jump ahead to 2017. I had friends that had gone on caribou hunts in Quebec and I had wanted to go, but never did. Then at a sports show in January I talked to a Quebec Outfitter, and he verified that Quebec was going to close caribou hunting to non-residents at the end of that year. So I booked a hunt.
That Outfitter had two fly in camps and just assigned hunters to each camp. Our hunt was susposed to be 2 hunters for each guide, but one of the guides was sick, so there were 3 of us in my group. I didn't know the other hunters, and in the canoe trip across the lake on opening morning, our guide asked who would get first shot. One of the other hunters suggested that the oldest hunter could shoot first. I just smiled and said that I was 71.
Since I had previously hunted caribou in Alaska and twice in the Northwest Territory, I turned down a bunch of bulls until I saw the bull in my avatar. He turned out to be one of the largest bulls that that outfitter shot that year and he easily me the B&C minimum.
Back at home when I had this bull scored, my friend asked me if I had entered my other caribou and Muskox for the Record Book. When I said no, he appeared hurt, so I said that I would enter them all. It was close to the deadline for entering animals for the 3 year B&C Awards Program, so I only had time to enter that caribou that year then entered the other 2 animals the next year.
It turned out that my bull scored high enough to be invited to the 30th B&C Awards Banquet at the Bass Pro headquarters in Springfield, MO. My bull won the 2nd place award for Quebec Labrador caribou for that 3 year period, so pictures and my story were also published in the 30th B&C Award Book. My sister and GF went with me to the awards ceremony.
A picture from the 30th B&C Asards book of two of us "elitist" Montana hunters at the Awards banquet.
The next year I did enter my Central Canadian Barren Ground Caribou and Muskox in B&C. That caribou was also invited to that Awards Ceremony, and although I didn't go to that ceremony, he won 1st place in his division, and again my pictures and story was published in the B&C 31st Awards Book.
Then when the latest B&C All Time Record Book came out, I was very humbled to see two half page pictures of me with my caribou in that book.