2024 Idaho ML Reg update: non-lead conicals allowed

[ritter26]

I just saw that Idaho is allowing non-lead, full-bore conical bullets from the 2024 muzzleloader-only controlled hunts.

Nice article here:

Idaho Expands Bullet Options For Muzzleloader Season

New for 2024 the Idaho Fish and Game Commission has expanded definitions regarding what are acceptable bullets during the muzzleloader only hunting seasons. Previously the regulations stipulated that all projectiles must be comprised of 100% lead, thus limiting legal bullets to lead round balls...

muzzle-loaders.com

During the last two years, I used 50 cal, 460 grain no excuses lead bullets with 80 grains of triple 7 fffg powder and ultra-light knight muzzleloader.

With these regulation changes, what are some of the best bullets you've used to improve accuracy and penetration compared to the no excuses bullets?

For a single bullet for both deer and elk, the muzzle-loader article and video above recommended power belt elr and thor bullets. Researching more there's lots of options like ballistic tip vs hollow point and lighting (one size fits all) vs hammer (customized to your bore), plastic vs metal base.

 

[Timberline001]

I’ll be shooting the 340 Hornady ELDx. 4 inches high at 100 gives me a point and shoot to 200 with 120 grs 777. That’s as far as I’ll shoot with my peep sight so that’s perfect for me.

 

[ElDiablito]

Thors are great bullets.

 

[farmermail]

I’ll be shooting the 340 Hornady ELDx. 4 inches high at 100 gives me a point and shoot to 200 with 120 grs 777. That’s as far as I’ll shoot with my peep sight so that’s perfect for me.

What twist rate works best with those?

 

[ElDiablito]

What twist rate works best with those?

There’re made for the standard 28 twist barrels.

 

[Timberline001]

What twist rate works best with those?

Hornady states 1:28 I believe. My Cva accura MR is a 1:28 and shoots them well.

 

[SamSlaysCritters]

Thors are great bullets.

I see you all over muzzy forums, and if you don't mind you seem like you know what you're talking about and I have some questions. I am shooting a Traditions Vortek with a 1/28 twist barrel. I'm planning on killing both an elk and a deer with it in Idaho this fall. Should I try the Thor bullets, or get the hornady bore pushers and the powerbelts and let them duke it out for top spot?

 

[ElDiablito]

I see you all over muzzy forums, and if you don't mind you seem like you know what you're talking about and I have some questions. I am shooting a Traditions Vortek with a 1/28 twist barrel. I'm planning on killing both an elk and a deer with it in Idaho this fall. Should I try the Thor bullets, or get the hornady bore pushers and the powerbelts and let them duke it out for top spot?

Well, if nothing else, I do have an opinion on muzzy topics. I’ve been hunting exclusively with a muzzy for about 35 years. I’m not a fan of anything Powerbelt makes. Certainly not for elk. The Hornady Bore Driver ELDX are a nice bullet and would be good for deer IMO. Fairly soft though - I’d go with a 300 gr Thor if I were hunting for both deer and elk.

 

[SamSlaysCritters]

Figured out I only have the muzzy for late season deer, so I went with the 338 Powerbelt Platinums and the 340 Bore Pushers. If neither of them shoot how I'd like I'll move to Thor or No Excuse bullets.

 

[Del Gue]

I just saw that Idaho is allowing non-lead, full-bore conical bullets from the 2024 muzzleloader-only controlled hunts.

Nice article here:

Idaho Expands Bullet Options For Muzzleloader Season

New for 2024 the Idaho Fish and Game Commission has expanded definitions regarding what are acceptable bullets during the muzzleloader only hunting seasons. Previously the regulations stipulated that all projectiles must be comprised of 100% lead, thus limiting legal bullets to lead round balls...

muzzle-loaders.com

During the last two years, I used 50 cal, 460 grain no excuses lead bullets with 80 grains of triple 7 fffg powder and ultra-light knight muzzleloader.

With these regulation changes, what are some of the best bullets you've used to improve accuracy and penetration compared to the no excuses bullets?

For a single bullet for both deer and elk, the muzzle-loader article and video above recommended power belt elr and thor bullets. Researching more there's lots of options like ballistic tip vs hollow point and lighting (one size fits all) vs hammer (customized to your bore), plastic vs metal base.

You already have the perfect elk medicine. I would see no reason to change. A 460 grain No Excuses or a 460 grain Bullshop are what I have used for elk in the past. They are accurate with the right charge and a wool wad hit elk like a freight train. I shoot mine out to 200 yds with a peep sight.