Bringing up an old thread, but I may have a variation to assist with woodland whitetail hunting that has been working well for me.
I first read Darin’s article 7-9 years ago, and found the trick pin system worked very well, especially for Elk where the ideal pin placement was lower edge of chest and tight to the front leg. This placed all impacts solidly in the lower section of an Elk’s chest from approximately 12-42 yards with a 50 yard trick pin. I used it for a quick shot in Wyoming on a steep up hill shot. Not sure the actual range of the Elk, but he was likely 30-40 yards. I remember my brother and hunting partner asked what yardage I shot for, and were baffled when I said “I don’t know.” They thought I was just flinging arrows carelessly. Ha!
I have since moved back east, and do not hunt elk as regularly as I once could. I have really focused on Whitetail hunting in the northeast and Kentucky. All public land woodlands where I do not generally expect shots more than 30-35 yards. The original trick pin system worked, but the proper POA is not as well defined on a deer. I never felt as consistent holding “somewhere” approximately 12” below my intended POI with my 50 yard pin. In practice I noticed shots at the mid ranges (25’ish yards) were impacting above a deers chest centerline. I have had negative issues in the past with high impacts on deer and wished to avoid that. I mainly went to a traditional pin hold method for shots, targeting to hit deer at their actual range.
This past season I may have found a solution for targeting woodland Whitetails using a single pin and single POA. I use a 35 yard pin as a “trick pin,” and hold the POA at the bottom edge of a deer’s chest, tight against the front leg. A very well defined POA, just like for Elk.
I find from the ground at approximately 8-30 yards all POI are within a 2” group, centered 6” above the POA (POI exactly 1/3 up the deer’s chest). From 10-28 yards the arrow shafts stack on top of each other in the same hole in the center of the group.
From a tree stand the steeper angle actually helps stretch this out a bit. I maintain solid hits to 32-33 yards with the same POA.
This past season I had my 3-pin sight setup for 20-35-50 yards. I trained myself to mostly ignore the 20 pin, and I successfully center punched a buck using the 35 pin with the aiming method described above. The buck was likely 24-27 yards from my stand.
I am going “all in” this season. My pins are set for 35-50-65 yards. All shots less than 30’ish yards will be completed with my 35 pin in “trick pin” fashion. If I go elk hunting, I still practice using the 50 yard trick pin too. The 65 yard pin has been a lot of fun during practice, and I have surprised myself how accurate I am at that range (makes the shorter shots easy now). With the consistent pin spacing I maintain the option to range a target and pin gap the shot accurately. I suspect I could refine this system of aiming with the pin set at 37-38 yards, instead of 35 yards. But I like the even pin spacing.
For reference my bow is shooting 281 fps. The included picture shows my 35 yard trick pin POA (yellow dot), and the arrows POI (red star) from approximately 8-30 yards. I hope this helps someone.
View attachment 697872