Hoodie
WKR
I find it interesting how many folks think this is a good theoretical internet banter but not much more than that.
I almost think the opposite.
1) Common stainless/synthetic bolt action
2) Pretty much any centerfire cartridge from .223 up to .300 win mag
3) Durable optic with a low end power of no more than 3x.
Given those criteria, I think most people could do pretty much any NA big game from up close and personal in the timber out to 500 yards or so (assuming appropriate training).
I used to get hung up on optimal barrel length and stuff, but I've killed my last two bucks from the ground in the timber at 40 and 90 yards with a 24 inch barrel. No real issues.
I almost think the opposite.
1) Common stainless/synthetic bolt action
2) Pretty much any centerfire cartridge from .223 up to .300 win mag
3) Durable optic with a low end power of no more than 3x.
Given those criteria, I think most people could do pretty much any NA big game from up close and personal in the timber out to 500 yards or so (assuming appropriate training).
I used to get hung up on optimal barrel length and stuff, but I've killed my last two bucks from the ground in the timber at 40 and 90 yards with a 24 inch barrel. No real issues.