Lawnboi
WKR
Curious why you wouldn't glass or sit at camp using a down quilt? I see no difference other than the weight to warmth ratio.
-Down absorbs moisture. Once its wet it takes quite a bit to dry it out. Where as synthetic dosnt hold as much moisture and dries redily
-Make any sizable hole in your down gear and you will have feathers everywhere, where as with synthetic, a small hole from an ember or small rip wouldn't cause any insulation loss.
Im no longer a huge fan of down, water repellent or not. I have owned down in the past and have always had a hard time keeping it completely dry. Down has its place, I just prefer synthetic.