Reinhart 18-1 compared to Morrell High roller

[Luked]

My old 18-1 is about shot out after 5 years.
This year done it in pretty bad.
Have any of you used both? which do you think is better or longer lasting?
I need to get something soon but not sure which one to get.

 

[CB4]

Im in the same boat. But the 18-1 is off my list in consideration now. I like the target but want more of a cube shape. Looking at the high roller, sevr and Big 8. I want something a little bigger. I have also contemplated the matrix but its hard to justify the cost.

 

[Luked]

Yea the Matrix seems like a nice target but man its pricey.
I am like you, want more of a cube type.

 

[Gen273]

I like the high roller; it has been a great target thus far.

 

[houghtonic]

Don’t forget the 365 targets. I have found them a little more durable and than the high roller.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[sveltri]

Having used both I would 100% of the time take the 18-1 over the high roller. The driver for me is multiple aiming points in the center of the target as opposed to having to dance around the edges .

 

[Hills]

I've had the Sevr for about a month and a half now. Had the 18-1 before that. I've been happy with the Sevr shooting field points and fixed blades into it. It is not my main target but has been shot a lot recently. I like the larger rectangular face compared to the 18-1 too.

 

[nphunter]

Love my 18-1, I've had lots of targets over the years and it's lasted the longest, I don't really use it as a main target, more of a travel target though.

 

[Billy Goat]

The Rhinoblock has a replaceable insert, if that helps.


I have been using Big Shot Slayer broadhead targets, but they aren't made anymore. I have been impressed with their durability.

 

[Hussar]

I have about 200 shots into a high roller (50/50 split of field points and broadheads). It's holding up very well and I only have shot one side so far. No experience with the Reinhart, but it's holding up much better than my delta McKenzie target did with broadheads.

 

[doc holiday13]

Check out "Blob" targets.. I've had the same one for about 8 years. I've left it outside in the elements and its still holds up great. My arrows penetrate a little deeper than when I first bought it but it still stops them. I wanna say mine is 24x24x10. Its heavy AF

 

[Mikido]

Get the rinehart XL block target. It has a replaceable core. I’ve had mine for 8 years, and replaced the core 3 times.

 

[CB4]

Camofire has the Delta Big 8s on it today. Blemished if that matters to you. Look like a good deal to me.

 

[Hans]

I've been shooting at my high roller target for over 3 years now... seems to be holding up quite well. I keep it out of the elements when I'm not shooting at it, which I think helps from the foam deteriorating too quickly.

 

[Archerichards]

Love my Rinoblock. Best target I ever bought, and looks like it will last quite a while. Superior to the High Rollers I was shooting.

And by the way, OP, if you got five years of life out of a target, I’d say you got your money’s worth out of it!