Target Question 18-1 vs High Roller

[Luked]

For you all that have used both of these.
How would you compare them?
I have two 18-1 but both are about shot out and I need to pick up a couple more targets for the house.

 

[TylerDurden3]

I like both but I think the Rinehart 18-1 lasts longer. The Rinehart also seems a little harder to remove arrows.

 

[NXTZ]

It’s been a few years since I had the high roller, but broadheads killled it pretty quick. My 18-1s have definitely lasted longer. I feel like I remember field points starting to pass through the high roller pretty quickly easily too.

The high roller does now have an accessory “surround” or expansion, so the red block acts as a replaceable core (but for the price I’d probably get a matrix)

 

[jonesn3]

High roller does not last long especially if using and amount of broadheads. Even field points tore it up good I noticed. I have a 3-4 year old high roller I picked up while on sale, can’t say I’d get another. Got an 18-in-1 about 5 years ago, it’s been shot out on one side with BHs, but still has sides intact and does appear much denser foam. That said, I would instead recommend something with a replaceable insert. Usually you can pickup BLEM inserts for a discount price and make the life of the target last much longer

 

[CMF]

Haven't tried the high roller, but I have the rhino block that has the replaceable insert. I've replaced the insert once now and it's still going strong. The insert is only 100 vs the new target of 260.

I wish Rinehart made a much bigger foam block target like 24 or 30". I'll probably try the 365 next.