Some more real use data
I was waiting on this review before purchasing a puffy, but with the First Lite sale a couple of weeks ago, I just had to try it. I also received the Kanab pants and Chugach Workshirt for Christmas. This was perfect timing since I just got back from a 5 day elk hunt. I can give my opinions on how they worked out. My stats are; 5'8'' tall, 180 lbs, 45" chest, 34" waist, and 31" inseam. The pants (medium) and shirt (large) fit better than most of my dress clothes (my wife agrees). They fit comfortably loose enough to wear a merino wool base layer underneath. They are well made and the ripstop works, I will explain later.
The pants are great. The only thing I did not like is that they only have a right rear pocket. I have been wearing a wallet for better than 45 years in my left rear pocket, it feels odd/uncomfortable to switch sides. I realize this will probably be a non issue for anyone else. I also hooked the pants on the truck tailgate the last morning and got a 2" tear. This was my bad, and I believe any other pair of pants I own would have torn just as much or more. I wore the pants the rest of the day, and the riptstop did not let the tear get any bigger. I will call the company today to see if they can be repaired (on my dime of course). I still plan on buying another pair for next years hunt. If I could add one recommendation it would be to add a left rear pocket.
I really like this shirt too. I did find out if you have your jacket zipped up all day, like I did on one cold day, the ripstop in the shirt collar irritated my neck and my got really red. Again, I still plan on buying one more shirt for next years hunt. If I could add one recommendation it would be to add a softer material on the inside of the shirt collar.
Now for the puffy jacket (large), this one is tough because I really loved this jacket, but I did have some issues. The good: The jacket felt like a feather compared to the Filson wool liner I had been using, and packs a whole lot smaller; The freedom of movement is amazing, it almost feels like you are not wearing anything; The fit is great, and fits just loose enough that I can also wear a light fleece jacket for colder conditions. The material is very windproof, and I do not think it can get any quieter without being a wool or fleece type of material. The jacket kept my core warmer than I thought possible for what seems like very thin insulation. Now for the bad: 1st, I did get a chance to wear the jacket with my gortex shell on top for a Christmas light parade and choir concert. The temperature was in the low 20's with a little breeze. I was basically standing still for about 2 1/2 hours and could feel the top of my arms getting cooler while my under arms and body core were nice and warm. I realize this is probably an issue with my metabolism and might not affect any one else. 2nd, Since day one I had trouble with the zipper snagging, a little jiggling always got it loose, except on the first morning of my hunt. The first morning the zipper got stuck so bad, it took me at least 5 minutes of pulling and yanking to get it unstuck, and then the zipper just fell off. I was really looking forward to giving the jacket a good test but ended up using the Filson for the whole hunt. I will call the company to see about my options, and I am sure they will make it right. If I could add recommendations: 1st, Add more insulation to the arms, or better yet, map more insulation to the outer part of the arm only; 2nd, Fix the zipper issue (then again I might have a lemon since no one else seems to have this issue). Finally, I never really got a chance to test the under arm breathable panels, but they seem kind of small, so maybe make them a little bigger.
I hope this info helps with adding actual usage data.