My initial response would be that the timing actually could be better and that's why your getting a low tear that won't go away. Internet forum "timing rules" don't usually apply to everyone. You need to time your cams to your hand position, aka "creep tuning" or equivalent.
That said, I haven't shot thru paper for about 30 years now. It works great if you have no idea where to initially set your rest and nock prior to actually tuning, or to confirm those settings, which is what most guys use paper for.
If a guy gets bullets thru paper then creep tunes and group tunes at 60, that 1/2" tear is close to where you'll end up anyway, if not more.