New Mexico officially bans scopes

[FrontierGander]

his is what happens when the modern industry touts 500- 600 - 800 yard shots with scoped muzzle loaders.

NM State Game Commission Bans Scopes on Muzzleloaders - New Mexico Wildlife Federation

By BEN NEARY NMWF Conservation Director Starting next year, New Mexico hunters who take to the field in designated muzzleloader seasons will no longer be able to use scope sights... Read more »

nmwildlife.org

 

[MuleyFever]

Good, hopefully more states follow and states like CO dont feel pressured to allow scopes.

 

[Jellymon1]

A modern muzzleloader with a modern scope IMO is a single shot modern firearm. The whole purpose of a muzzleloader or bow season, and why the better seasons are given to them, is because it is harder/more limiting. I hunt all 3 weapons and agree that for healthy hunters muzzleloader only seasons should be left open sights.

 

[100%DIYazCOUES]

perfect!

 

[HuntHarder]

Fantastic, I hope Arizona takes notice and follows suit soon.

 

[OXN939]

Love it. Been a while since I've ruffled the LR muzzleloader crowd's feathers, so I'll observe this again... by the time you get to 400 yards, a stout hunting load from a CVA Paramount is in the same ballistic territory as lever action .357 Trapper carbines that you often hear are too anemic for whitetail.

Keep scopes out of the world of western muzzleloader hunting.

 

[amassi]

Make muzzle loaders primitive again

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

 

[dsotm]

Fuddtastic

 

[Rich M]

Love it. Been a while since I've ruffled the LR muzzleloader crowd's feathers, so I'll observe this again... by the time you get to 400 yards, a stout hunting load from a CVA Paramount is in the same ballistic territory as lever action .357 Trapper carbines that you often hear are too anemic for whitetail.

Keep scopes out of the world of western muzzleloader hunting.

I use a 357 mag bolt rifle and love it.

W some practice, a ML guy can probably get 150 yards out of iron sights. 200 if they use one of those peep site with crosshair things.

 

[TreeWalking]

I use a 357 mag bolt rifle and love it.

W some practice, a ML guy can probably get 150 yards out of iron sights. 200 if they use one of those peep site with crosshair things.

I hunted in NV with a muzzleloader using a rear peep with a front bead which I bought and installed for just that hunt as before had a 0 power scope.. By 150 yards at the range, the front bead was basically the size of the 12" target zone. I could line up okay but was not reassuring so I was not shooting out that far even at a bull elk unless a follow-up on a hit bull. Fortunately, the bull walked up out of a creek bed bugling for about the 150th time that morning so the shot was about 30 yards.

 

[Stubborn_bowhunter]

I'd take a primitive archery season too.

 

[hunting1]

I’m glad they finally did!

 

[LabMan]

Never made sense to allow modern scopes for a primitive hunt. Disallowing them brings it back to the original intent.

 

[dsotm]

Never made sense to allow modern scopes for a primitive hunt. Disallowing them brings it back to the original intent.

We should ban bow sights and compound bows too, right?

 

[87TT]

GOOD

 

[canyonhunter47]

Fantastic, I hope Arizona takes notice and follows suit soon.

I agree and hope this means I can draw faster

 

[KHNC]

We should ban bow sites and compound bows too, right?

why ban bowsite? Not as good as rokslide, but its a good forum

 

[GMB54-120]

PRB and real black only while we are at it. We dont want anything modern right?

 

[JPD350]

I am not sure what unit it was but Kuiu just sent out a muzzle elk hunt video, 1st shot was something like 548 yds, he missed only because he didn't compensate for wind drift, the hight of the shot was perfect. The 2nd shot was over 4 hundred and he killed the elk.
I am very sure based on my observations and knowledge of unit 15 in NM the mature bull elk numbers have been pummeled since the onslaught of scoped muzzle loaders.
There is a reason there are typically no rifle hunts during the rut, eventually the predominant bulls are small or raghorns.

 

[dsotm]