This east coast weather gave me an opportunity to test gear in 20 degree temps and sleet/snow. Put some of the recommendations above to the test for about 3 hours.
Today I rocked the woolshell pants, mesh base layers, merino short sleeve T-shirt, Atlantic rancher sweater mentioned above, Patagonia Houdini, elk skin gloves, wool beanie, vivobarefoot trackers, injinji liner socks and yak wool socks.
Temperature when I started was 20 degrees. As I started shoveling I had to ditch the sweater. I imagine hiking in that sweater it would not be my preferred, unless it was super cold. I tend to run hot, and this was no different than what I’m used to hiking. Used the Houdini over the Woolnet and T-shirt and was still pretty warm but not sweating noticeably. The sweater is nice, I’m sure it is better as 100% merino but I don’t know if I need it. I’m still split on if this or my first spear wool pull over is a better layer.
Hands were not cold as the gloves were mostly dry (only started to get colder later when the leather got wet). Swapped to a set of wool lined leather gloves when I stopped shoveling.
Feet were nice and warm. Didn’t end up feeling cold until I did some post holing in the snow to help my kids sled and then stood around for a while. Still not uncomfortable but would probably need some water resistant boots with some liner or some mukluk style for sitting when glassing.
The Houdini ended up getting wet, it wasn’t making me cold but I would have been better served with a rain jacket as the water/wind barrier. I ended up switching later when helping the kids sled and I was doing less active work.
Woolshell pants definitely need suspenders vs a belt. Just no way to keep them high enough based on how they are cut. I’ll look to remedy that. They were warm and did their job all afternoon despite getting some snow on them.
Wool beanie always works. No need to change it. I have a knit and standard style from duckworth.
Overall I feel good with my choices. If I were weight conscious the Atlantic rancher might not make the cut, but it’s nice. Everything else works as it has before. If I was doing extended cold weather I’d probably get some mittens or something similar. Still need to settle on a set of down puffy pants before next season.