Mid-Layer Shootout Review ***Updated 2/18/23***

TBOArcher

FNG
Joined
Mar 24, 2023
Messages
10
Gents - the fine folks from Rokslide have asked me to do a mid-layer shootout and I agreed. We were hoping to complete it in the Spring when the weather was more favorable (cooler temps), but were waiting on a few additional mid-layers. We still haven't received the Kuiu 240 yet.

Thus far we've got the First Lite Origin hoody, Sitka Heavyweight hoody and the Sitka Arrowhead MDWi hoody (that I reviewed earlier).

I want to look at several things, but near the top are warmth/weight and moisture movement. I think I might have a pretty slick way to compare moisture movement. I had an ah ha moment after I was swept by a fast moving stream this past winter. I was wet up to my neck, base layer soaked. I put on a mid-layer and started hiking (hard) for ~ two hours and lo behold, my base layer was very close to being fully dry.

I'm not volunteering for any swift water sweeps :D, but my thought is taking a base layer (using the same one each time) soaking it with water-, writing it slightly and weighing it (insuring that each time the garment weighs the same). Putting it on and donning one of the mid-layers. Using a 4-5 mile route (again using the same route & pace each time) and then weighing both the base layer and mid-layer. Obviously the lighter each is (less moisture), the better. I'll do my best to keep environmental conditions as close to the same each time- temperature, humidity, etc.

Anyways Robby suggested starting a q & a thread to get ideas from folks on testing, other possible candidates, etc.

As summer is almost here in Montana, probably realistically looking at September to give this a go.

***Update*** The four pieces included in the review are the OR Vigor Hoodie, the First Lite Origin Hoody, the Sitka Ambient Hoody, and the Stonge Glacier Cirque Lite Jacket.

Mid-Layer Shootout Review

Thanks
Mike
Thanks for the review. Very helpful.
 

Bump79

WKR
Joined
Oct 5, 2020
Messages
924
I had tried the old Sitka Kelvin Active half sleeve and got it for a deal @$110. I liked it but didn't love it and decided to return. I think I appreciate it more now after more experiences with similar styles.

I just saw it in sub-alpine for $75 on Sierra Trading Post.. I definitely like it for that price! Ordered.1 left in size large.

 
OP
mtwarden

mtwarden

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 18, 2016
Messages
9,484
Location
Montana
I still have mine; if I happen to be hunting in warmer weather- it would be the mid-layer most likely to be grabbed :) if not warmer weather, probably the last to grab
 

Stoop

FNG
Joined
Mar 29, 2023
Messages
11
How does a Patagonia Thermal Weight Hoody compare to a Kuiu Peloton 97 Hoody, warmth-wise?
 
OP
mtwarden

mtwarden

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 18, 2016
Messages
9,484
Location
Montana
How does a Patagonia Thermal Weight Hoody compare to a Kuiu Peloton 97 Hoody, warmth-wise?

I'd say it's a little warmer than the 97 and also breathes a little better. But it's also heavier ~ 8oz vs ~ 5 oz.
 

Stoop

FNG
Joined
Mar 29, 2023
Messages
11
I'd say it's a little warmer than the 97 and also breathes a little better. But it's also heavier ~ 8oz vs ~ 5 oz.
Wow, that's surprising. I own the Thermal Weight Hoody (actually the precursor, the Expedition Weight Hoody), but I assumed the Peloton 97 was the warmer one. Interesting.
 
OP
mtwarden

mtwarden

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 18, 2016
Messages
9,484
Location
Montana
The Peloton 97, weight for weight is really warm- I think the Thermal weight edges it a little in the warmth dept., but it also 35% heavier. The reason I choose it as a base layer over the 97, is it breathes better.
 

Stoop

FNG
Joined
Mar 29, 2023
Messages
11
The Peloton 97, weight for weight is really warm- I think the Thermal weight edges it a little in the warmth dept., but it also 35% heavier. The reason I choose it as a base layer over the 97, is it breathes better.
What do you choose as a midlayer?
 
OP
mtwarden

mtwarden

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 18, 2016
Messages
9,484
Location
Montana
Depends- early hunting season (warmer) I'll often grab the Sitka Active hoody (half sleeve); later likely the Arrowhead MDWi, if I'm going to be hunting a lot of thick timber/blowdown I might grab the Core Heavyweight hoody

Summer I usually use the Peloton 97 hoody (over an OR Echo hoody base layer)

I didn't care for the Thermalweight hoody as a mid-layer, works great as a base layer in cold though
 
OP
mtwarden

mtwarden

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 18, 2016
Messages
9,484
Location
Montana
some of it's due to fit, it's a little tight to go over a base layer and two, I've found not to be overly effective at moving moisture when it's over a base layer- on it's against the skin, it does a pretty good job. The second might be related to the first, not sure- just my experience.
 
Joined
Nov 30, 2022
Messages
44
Can you toss in an Arcteryx Leaf Naga Hoody in full or pullover ? They have been my go to.
I was just thinking about how the full zip compares to the Ambient. I’ve been rocking a naga full zip as my go to mid layer since they came out, but I’ve been very intrigued by the ambient.
 

pcros27

FNG
Joined
Aug 15, 2022
Messages
42
Yeah I can put together a a chart pretty easily. I don't have any scientific testing equipment, but I have few ideas for testing that I think will bear fruit- if nothing else will be interesting :D

Was out yesterday with the First Lite Origin hoody; 12-16" of snow and 10 miles kicked my a$$!

YDK7JIX.jpg
Have you run the Klamath? How's this compare for warmth, etc?
 
OP
mtwarden

mtwarden

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 18, 2016
Messages
9,484
Location
Montana
Have you run the Klamath? How's this compare for warmth, etc?

I haven't. I'd take a stab at your question based on the fabric (polartec grid fleece) and weight. My best guess that this would be in the warmth category of the OR Vigor I tested- very similar fabric and only an ounce difference in weight (which probably amounts to the hood on the Vigor vs the hoodless Klamath).

If you're looking for a lightweight, hoodless mid-layer- grid fleece is pretty well proven out. It likely won't be as warm as the others mid-layers tested though.
 

Bump79

WKR
Joined
Oct 5, 2020
Messages
924
I haven't. I'd take a stab at your question based on the fabric (polartec grid fleece) and weight. My best guess that this would be in the warmth category of the OR Vigor I tested- very similar fabric and only an ounce difference in weight (which probably amounts to the hood on the Vigor vs the hoodless Klamath).

If you're looking for a lightweight, hoodless mid-layer- grid fleece is pretty well proven out. It likely won't be as warm as the others mid-layers tested though.
I wonder about the Vigor Plus. Heavier obviously but more loft than the Vigor. Good price point as OR is pretty easily found 25% off.

It says "mid-layer" to me more than the Vigor.

 
OP
mtwarden

mtwarden

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 18, 2016
Messages
9,484
Location
Montana
I wonder about the Vigor Plus. Heavier obviously but more loft than the Vigor. Good price point as OR is pretty easily found 25% off.

It says "mid-layer" to me more than the Vigor.


Yeah in hindsight I probably should have chosen the Plus for the test; it would have compared more closely I think. Of course @Ryan Avery suggested that one, guess I should have listened :D
 
OP
mtwarden

mtwarden

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 18, 2016
Messages
9,484
Location
Montana
Interesting.

They used to have a Deviator in their lineup that was also a hybrid. It also used Polartec Alpha Direct (assuming this is Direct or a derivative) for the front shoulders and then a grid fleece for the arms and back.

This new one they continued the Direct into the arms, but left just the back in grid.

If you're wearing a pack the entire time or doing something very active, ie trail running, nordic skiing, etc- I can definitely see this piece being of interest :)
 
Top