- Joined
- Oct 22, 2014
- Messages
- 10,402
Pictures or it didn't happen? I would take a guy at his word on what he saw as a guide, but I'm about as far from having a dog in this fight as could be, I shoot monos from a medium bore.
What does being a guide mean? You don’t go to medical school to become one- most are just cowboys or ranch hands. I’m not sure why some expertise is assigned to them as a group- the average knowledge level about terminal ballistics and animal anatomy is very poor in the vast majority of guides I have met. The majority I have met still believe there is a “gap” above the lungs and below the spine.
I have seen 60-80 elk shot with ELD-M’s, TMK’s, Bergers, Match Burners, etc- from 20’ish yards to over 1,100 yards, a lot of those being put through the “shoulders” and even trying to purposely hit the scapula and humerus joint (knuckle) we just can’t seem to get these magical “shoulders” that stop bullets.
There is 3-4 inches of muscle over the scapula, and the scapula itself is as thin as standard cardboard. To grasp what saying “the shoulder stopped the bullet” means- that is literally trying to say that a 140+ grain bullet “blew up” in a squirrel and then couldn’t penetrate a piece of cardboard from a shoe box. It’s ridiculous and brings about confusion how anyone that has deboned an elk and looked at it could think that the “shoulder” is stopping any legit bullet.