Is AZ PointGuard PLUS a scam?

Spoony

FNG
Joined
Jul 22, 2022
Messages
67
Like some others here, I apply to almost all western states, every year, for all big game species, trying to either amass a pile preference/bonus points or get lucky. It takes a great deal of money, effort, and dedication to understand the nuances for each states draw requirements, to avoid missing application deadlines and to protect those points. And it is a stressful game. It is a game where it is not difficult to lose your points. A simple act like missing consecutive applications can cause your points to vanish in a big expensive heart breaking cloud of smoke. I recently lost all of my AZ elk points to a simple oversite. I am now 46 years old and do not have enough time to accrue the points I once had and still be able to do a good packout. Poof, dream AZ elk hunt gone for good, just like that.

This year a buddy and I decided to apply as a group to a premier super-secret AZ elk unit for a once in a life archery elk hunt. We applied, he filled out the application like we have done before, life was good, until the results came out. He called me to tell me he screwed up and accidently applied for a cow tag. We now have 2 cow tags in a killer unit and 0 points. I want to be clear that we share equal responsibility with this mistake. If my points were important, I could have spent 2 minutes to verify the application was correct. The previous year I had purchased PointGuard Plus which is valid for 3 draw cycles. I instinctively assumed for years 1 draw cycle = 1 year. I paid dearly for this mistake.

PointGuard Plus is a program you can buy into that allows you to be able to return a tag and points restored for any reason for all eligible big game species for 3 draw cycles. It is important to understand what a draw cycle is and isn't, because Arizona Game and Fish does not explicitly tell you. There are 3 "big game" draw cycles in 1 year that deduct from your allotment of 3 draw cycles. Essentially, PointGuard Plus is good for 1 year only. Remember this if nothing else.

Is AZ Game and Fish intentionally vague to scam people from their earned points to combat point creep? Are they intentionally vague to avoid the regulations associated with making PointGuard look like an insurance policy? Who knows, but I do know it would be easy for AZ to clarify PointGuard Plus is an annual program rather than using some underdefined draw cycle concept. At a minimum, AZ should try their hardest to clarify common misconceptions and misunderstandings with the programs they offer. We are dedicated to them and their animals, they need to return the favor.

It's been on my mind, this is how I chose to deal with it, sorry for all the words, and I sincerely hope someone reads this and this information prevents someone from losing their coveted AZ points.

Few lessons learned to protect your points (and additional tips). Please correct me if I am wrong, as I am sure you will.
  • PointGuard Plus is good for 1 year (or 3 "big game" draw cycles).
  • PointGuard Plus can be purchased after you fill out an application, up to the draw cycle deadline.
  • A draw cycle will be removed from your PointGuard Plus allotment of 3 draw cycles, regardless if you apply in that draw cycle or not.
  • Use AI to develop intelligent questions and call those fish and game departments until you understand everything. Those people at the game depts are usually helpful, informative, and well trained.
  • Double check those applications for the correct units, hunt dates, type of weapon, species and sex.
  • Check that application your buddy filled out, no matter how good he is at killing big animals. Mistakes are made easily. Spend 10 seconds to have him text a photo of the application, it's that easy.
  • Don't be me, apply early, seriously. Nothing sucks more than to apply late on the day of the deadline to realize the deadline is at 5 pm, not at midnight like you assumed, and now you only have 15 minutes to apply (watch out for New Mexico). This is an easy way to make terrible mistakes.
  • Use GoHunt to export the draw deadlines into your work and personal calendar. Never miss another deadline, your points depend on it in some states. (Nevada, Montana, Colorado and Utah want your points)
  • Apply, apply, apply. Luck has happened to me.
  • Set aside a secret bank account that you use only for big game applications, and don't tell your wife about it. She won't understand.
  • Make your complaints heard. They serve us.

Draw cycle deadlines are:
Winter (~Feb) Draw Cycle: Elk, Antelope
Summer (~Jun) Draw Cycle: Turkey, Sheep, Deer, Bison, Javelina
Fall (~Oct) Draw Cycle: Turkey, Bison, Javelina, Bear
 
Don’t worry. Live and learn. You and your friend can donate the cow elk tags to the Arizona Wounded Warrior Program if you don’t want to hunt. You will help out unknown veterans if you donate the tags. A somewhat similar situation happened to me…

I never buy any of the “insurance” products in any states. In 2022, about 2 days before the deadline, I quickly slapped down unresearched hunt choices for nonresident desert bighorn sheep and antlered mule deer with 12 or 13 points each.

Results posted and I somehow drew both tags - a great DBHS unit in the Kofa’s and a marginal deer unit outside Phoenix. I hunted the DBHS tag and donated the mule deer tag to the Wounded Warrior Program.

I should have researched the mule deer units but hell, I was lucky 🍀 enough to draw a desert bighorn sheep tag at the same time. Pure dumb luck!

Good luck in the future and happy hunting to all, TheGrayRider a/k/a Tom.
 
It's gotten pretty hard to screw up the online application as the hunt #, unit, dates and bull/antlerless are clearly marked when you click your selection.

Point guard is pretty well defined as well and we've had to use it on a couple of occasions. Point Guard plus just saves you a few bucks if you want it for all species.

My wife has near max points for deer and last year by all accounts was a down year for antler growth on the Strip. She donated her Strip tag to OE4A. Due to PG she got to keep her points and a deserving Vet or Kid got to hunt the strip.

If you blew your points and paid for the tag I'd come on down and enjoy the AZ elk scene. Archery cow during the rut can be an amazing experience, or if anything like the past few years the rut has been late and you can be in for a challenging experience especially if you don't know the unit.

Good luck!
 
And this is why some people should just pay for a service to do the heavy lifting. Pretty cheap insurance if life can get in the way.

You lose points in AZ by missing 5 consecutive years of applying. You have to try pretty hard to get that done.
 
At some point during the app process it tells you if you are eligible for point guard or not, and if eligible at some point it asks if you want to add it. If you ignored that prompt because you thought your previous purchase was still good then that was your mistake.

Lots of us have made mistakes during applications. I did it and drew a late archery tag rather than an early tag. Poof went the points as there was no Point Guard then. Nothing to do about that except to go hunt. I still killed a bull and ate well for another year :)
 
Not being able to read and understand what it entails does not make it a scam. It got me a surrendered deer tag two years ago so I'll keep using it.
 
For those of you who think it is not a scam, justify your reasoning rather than making a 3 word comment. Go on the AZ pointguard page and tell us why you believe it is not a scam. Why is it clear to some but not others? I am simply asking questions. The incentive is there. AZ could allow you to return tags w/o PG, but they choose not to. Is PG to scam you out of money? Points? Both?

And yes, it is not about the antlers. It's about the pride and gratification behind those antlers. That the effort spent paid off. I do not think many would disagree that it is easier to kill a cow than a big bull. Ask yourself if there is more satisfaction in coming home with a 400+ bull or a young cow. They both fill the freezer.

Thank you to the person who suggested a donation to AZ Wounded Warrior. That may make it all worth it.
 
For those of you who think it is not a scam, justify your reasoning rather than making a 3 word comment. Go on the AZ pointguard page and tell us why you believe it is not a scam. Why is it clear to some but not others? I am simply asking questions. The incentive is there. AZ could allow you to return tags w/o PG, but they choose not to. Is PG to scam you out of money? Points? Both?

And yes, it is not about the antlers. It's about the pride and gratification behind those antlers. That the effort spent paid off. I do not think many would disagree that it is easier to kill a cow than a big bull. Ask yourself if there is more satisfaction in coming home with a 400+ bull or a young cow. They both fill the freezer.

Thank you to the person who suggested a donation to AZ Wounded Warrior. That may make it all worth it.
Well, scams deceive you and/or don’t provide you with the item/services/investment/etc you paid for. In the case of point guard, if you purchase it and choose to use it, you get your points back. So, it can’t be a scam.

If you had purchased it and went to use it and they didn’t give you your points back…that would be a scam.

Why is it clear to others and not you? I am not sure why others have the ability to read and comprehend and you don’t. I read it once and understood what it did and I had a high school GPA of 2.6. Remember you asked.

States could allow for a lot of things different in their draw system but they don’t. Maybe states should offer to hold your hand through the entire application process so this doesn’t happen.

I get it. That sucks. I would be pissed too. But where you direct that frustration is more important. You applied for the wrong hunt. You didn’t buy point guard. You don’t get to blame Arizona.
 
I am sure there are more administrative costs associated with re-issueing tags. I would imagine they (hopefully), come out net ahead on the cost of re-issueing tags vs the $ they take in on point guard. Someone has to go back in, change bonus points back to what they were before the draw, take points out of the new tag holders account. They have time in looking at the next in line for said tag, calling to see if they want it and possibly calling more people if the first few don't want it. They also have to reprint the tag, in many cases, and pay postage to mail it.
 
For those of you who think it is not a scam, justify your reasoning rather than making a 3 word comment.
It sounds like you are trying to justify your grievances and blame anyone else, rather than own your own mistake. Wild to ask people to "justify" their answers when year after year most people apply and dont have these issues.

You screwed up, you didnt read the regs, you didnt even apply for your own tag.

Youre going to get some shitty answers from people because you chose the blame route rather than saying "hey learn from my mistakes"
 
I get so many emails from AZGFD, and it seems like every third one is about point guard, pg+ and the difference between them. Hey have always said 3 draw cycles, not years nor implied years. The cycle in which you buy it, and the next two. So if you bought it for the elk/ant draw last year it was good for that draw, the fall(deer,etc) and spring( turkey, jav.etc) and then done. I think you ASSUMED they meant the next 3 elk/ant draws, but it’s spelled out in the regs what it is, and has been in their emails as well.
Putting in for cow instead of bull happens quite a bit, actually. Or rifle instead of archery. It sucks, but you have to verify hunt #( write it down from the regs if you need to), dates, sex, weapon. It’s all on the line you click.
The deadline for paper apps in person or mail YEARS ago was 5pm, which was close of business. Then they made it 7p on the deadline day so people getting off work at 5 could make it to an office. Since online started it has been 11:59pm Az time, not sure where you got 5pm online?
I respect you taking part of the blame for your buddy. You’re mad, but I guarantee he feels worse about it.
Last thing! You weren’t going to shoot a 400” bull. I mean maybe? But you weren’t. Even if it was “ super secret” most awesome unit ever, lol.
 
It sucks for sure. It does happen fairly often that people mistakenly put in for the antlerless tag and only find out when they draw it. I almost did myself just applying using the year before hunt numbers, after that I'm much more careful.



Sent from my SM-S926U using Tapatalk
 
It sucks but it was just a mistake. Point guard is not a scam.
On another note there are no super secret bull elk tags in Az. I lived there for 40 years and I did taxidermy for the last 10 years of that. I guarantee I’ve heard about the unit your referring to.
 
I wish they would do away with point guard. I think it would help with point creep. If you don’t think you can make a hunts dates work on a given year then only put in for points, let someone else who can make it work have a better chance at drawing.
 
Back
Top