Is a 6.5 PRC enough? Do I need a 7mm?

mxgsfmdpx said:
You have a synopsis you could share? I’m not a fan in general of the very few pieces I’ve listened to from those guys. Maybe this one is different?
Click to expand...
This is Jim Shockey
mxgsfmdpx said:
“Carry the energy as far as possible” lol. I turned it off after that sorry.
Click to expand...
Yeah ? I guess Jim doesn’t know much….


Hunting & Conservation Awards

 
BCDJR said:
This is Jim Shockey

Yeah ? I guess Jim doesn’t know much….


Hunting & Conservation Awards

Click to expand...

What does any it that have to do with factual terminal ballistics?

Just saying “Jim says so” is an appeal to authority fallacy.
 
Formidilosus said:
What does any it that have to do with factual terminal ballistics?

Just saying “Jim says so” is an appeal to authority fallacy.
Click to expand...
He refers in the video that his input was from the Hornady family who was on a 5 day bear hunt with him. Think the Hornady family knows a bit? Combined with his decades of guiding and personally hunting he has tremendous credibility.
 
BCDJR said:
He refers in the video that his input was from the Hornady family who was on a 5 day bear hunt with him. Think the Hornady family knows a bit? Combined with his decades of guiding and personally hunting he has tremendous credibility.
Click to expand...

Again- that is an appeal to authority. Why do I need to “think” anyone knows anything?

The information about what bullets factually do in tissue is available, and it has nothing to do with a name or a family.
 
BCDJR said:
This is Jim Shockey

Yeah ? I guess Jim doesn’t know much….


Hunting & Conservation Awards

Click to expand...
Sorry I don’t know what any of those accolades mean and I’ve never met him. I’m not interested in those types of things personally.

I’m a huge proponent of “use what you want” cartridge wise for killing. But when your “advice” for moose and bear is “300 PRC because only the military and hornady got to use it and it carries the energy” I’m turning you off my phone screen sorry.

If in person, we can have a good conversation about “energy” and maybe learn a few things from each other. That’s what I’m interested in.
 
BCDJR said:
Watch the video…he learned a lot from the Hornady’s. Dont assume
Click to expand...
You think Hornady flew up there to educate Jim? You do know he is sponsored and paid by Hornady right?

After his Hornady sponsor visited Jim, he now needs a shiny new 300 PRC, burning 80 grains of powder, with 40lbs of recoil?

The OP's question, a 6.5 PRC is enough at about 20lbs recoil, shot placement, with a good bullet, it will pernitrate the vitals and put big game down. It is enough for big game and it is basically a modern 270 Win with higher BC bullets, burns around 60 grain powder, 120gr - 150gr bullets.
 
OK since someone reported someone for name calling, I had to go back through this thread and delete several posts from several people that were arguing, bickering, name calling, or just didn't even apply to the original topic.

Stay on topic, engage in conversation about said topic, stating your opinion for either side and keep it civil or this thread will unfotunalty be locked
 
BCDJR said:
He refers in the video that his input was from the Hornady family who was on a 5 day bear hunt with him. Think the Hornady family knows a bit? Combined with his decades of guiding and personally hunting he has tremendous credibility.
Click to expand...
You are being sold snake oil by rich fudd's dressed up like Ted Nugent...

Listen to episodes 469,470, and 479. Also check out tha 6mm/264, 223, and 6.5 threads on this forum for lots of evidence of "small" caliber effectiveness. Once you emerge from the cave and see that you were simply interpreting shadows of reality you will then be able to see the truth and base your actions on evidence based reasoning. We all have to make assumptions but when we have good data we need to use it otherwise the terrorists win. At the moment it appears your reasoning is purely assumptions and hearsay which is appropriate when you have insignificant amounts of data to work with.

exomtngear.com

Hunt Backcountry Podcast Archive

The Hunt Backcountry Podcast has one purpose: to give you the information you need to become a more capable, confident, and successful backcountry hunter. Our focus is to bring you the most value possible by sharing information from experienced hunters — information that you can understand and...
exomtngear.com exomtngear.com
 
A 6.5mm PRC is just a magnum 6.5mm Creedmoor.

It adds about 250 FPS of muzzle velocity -- at the cost of roughly 50% more recoil.
 
BCDJR said:
If you can accurately shoot bigger guns as well why not.
Click to expand...
From my experience, that "if" is doing a lot of work and people just aren't honest with themselves. Everyone can make their own choices, but for me, my practice and shooting have gotten so much better since dropping down in recoil. After years of "the recoil doesn't bother me".
 
Diamondback said:
You think Hornady flew up there to educate Jim? You do know he is sponsored and paid by Hornady right?

After his Hornady sponsor visited Jim, he now needs a shiny new 300 PRC, burning 80 grains of powder, with 40lbs of recoil?

The OP's question, a 6.5 PRC is enough at about 20lbs recoil, shot placement, with a good bullet, it will pernitrate the vitals and put big game down. It is enough for big game and it is basically a modern 270 Win with higher BC bullets, burns around 60 grain powder, 120gr - 150gr bullets.
Click to expand...
Are not all PRC of Hornady heritage? So he could have endorsed them all or none
 
BCDJR said:
Are not all PRC of Hornady heritage? So he could have endorsed them all or none
Click to expand...
This is an advertisement that appeals to a certain market segment. You dont hire a guy in snake skin boots to try to sell feminine European calibers like 6.5mm. Hornady is trying to reach every customer to include the suburban desk jockey cowboy.
 
Packmansion said:
This is an advertisement that appeals to a certain market segment. You dont hire a guy in snake skin boots to try to sell feminine European calibers like 6.5mm. Hornady is trying to reach every customer to include the suburban desk jockey cowboy.
Click to expand...
Nailed it. They’re all paid to say what they’re saying and to appeal to each of their individual audiences. It’s all bullshit. They didn’t kill it with a 300 PRC. They killed it with a 200gr. 30 cal bullet going 2800fps. They’re just paid to say “PRC” or creedmoor or whatever is in their contract. It’s so blatantly obvious. People on TV or with large YouTube channels only say what they’re paid to say. They’ll use junk and tell you how great it is too, if that company pays them enough.
 
BCDJR said:
This is Jim Shockey

Yeah ? I guess Jim doesn’t know much….


Hunting & Conservation Awards

Click to expand...
My dad killed a ton of really nice bucks. Using a 16 gauge shotgun with buckshot. While I like and respect Jim a lot, those awards don’t mean he understands the terminal ballistics of smaller cartridges.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

T
20 vs 24 inch 6.5 prc
Replies
13
Views
387
Packmansion
P
L
Is a 20 inch 6.5 PRC enough for elk?
2 3 4
Replies
79
Views
4K
Pistolpete28
Pistolpete28
The Guide
7mm Backcountry, does BC stand for best choice or bad cartridge? Let's test it!
2 3
Replies
55
Views
3K
khuber84
K
D
Just one rifle owner's experience...
Replies
2
Views
412
JackButler
J
H
Is the Browning xbolt 7RM magazine the same size as a xbolt 6.5 prc magazine?
Replies
1
Views
121
WKR
WKR

Latest posts

Featured Video

Latest Articles

Back
Top