Are most elk hunters that transition from more "traditional" broadheads to the single bevel Iron Will broadheads using the same weight Iron Wills, or increasing significantly their total arrow weight as suggested by Ranch Fairy?
No- ranch fairy is not the person you want to take advice from on a lot of things. Most especially his arrow choices. A few of his points I agree on that are basically common sense and nothing “revolutionary”.
You need to find adequately weighted arrows for your draw weight/length that can provide enough speed to keep the pin gaps on your sight reasonable at your maximum effective range.
If you hunt pigs at a feeder out to 30 yards from a known shot distance that is not variable, then you can go 600+ grains of a cue stick for an arrow. Trajectory doesn’t matter in that style of “hunting” in Texas.
Almost every other real hunting situation is dynamic to the point where shot distances change by a moment’s notice, and trajectory becomes an important consideration. If you hit a tree or animal with your range finder, then draw your bow and the shot opportunity is now different, you’ll wish the 40-50 yard pin gap didn’t have an inch of separation, like you’ll have shooting a 240 fps arrow. Rutting elk don’t stand still very long when coming into a call like a pig with its head buried in a corn pile.
I think a middle of the road set up will take care of most of your hunting situations. With a 70 lb draw, arrow weight around 500 grains, 150 grain fixed head- that’s shooting about 275-285 fps. You’ll tune better than a 300+fps bow, pin gaps aren’t bad, and the energy will take down anything you can get your tag on.
It’s a bit heavier than a set up I’d use if I’d shoot only deer, but I don’t like changing things for different species because tuning takes time if you’re doing it right.