fatlander
WKR
- Joined
- Feb 11, 2016
- Messages
- 2,117
I’ve killed a bull with an iron will and I lost a bull that should have and most likely died with a SEVR.
The bull I killed with an iron will was uphill from me at the shot. High lung shot. He trotted down hill to my elevation for another lung shot. He tumbled down the hill for another 35 yards where I put another lung shot in him. Took him about a minute to expire with 3 double lung shots. Elk are tough.
The bull I lost with a SEVR was a high lung shot. Arrow disappeared in him. I presume it passed through as I couldn’t see it hanging out upon his retreat, but we never located the arrow. About 1.5 minutes after the shot, we heard him fall ~250 yards from the shot. We searched for hours to never find a single drop of blood, the arrow, or the bull. There’s not a doubt in my mind that the sound we heard was him falling. We just never located him.
I’ve killed about 15 animals with SEVRs. They haven’t impressed me. Blood trails always tended to be lacking in comparison to grim reapers (largely because of the 3 blades vs. 2). SEVRs aren’t very sharp from the factory and they’re a PIA to sharpen. The bull I lost probably wouldn’t have ever bleed that well from any broadhead given how high the shot was, but I still expected to find at least some blood.
If you’ve got the energy for a 1.75” SEVR you’ve got the energy for a 1.25 or 1.5” grim reaper fatal steel. I’ve killed somewhere in the neighborhood of 30 animals with grim reapers. Maybe close to 40, they’re by and large my favorite mechanical. The slogan “watch them drop” has been my overwhelming experience from shooting them at game.
The bull I killed with an iron will was uphill from me at the shot. High lung shot. He trotted down hill to my elevation for another lung shot. He tumbled down the hill for another 35 yards where I put another lung shot in him. Took him about a minute to expire with 3 double lung shots. Elk are tough.
The bull I lost with a SEVR was a high lung shot. Arrow disappeared in him. I presume it passed through as I couldn’t see it hanging out upon his retreat, but we never located the arrow. About 1.5 minutes after the shot, we heard him fall ~250 yards from the shot. We searched for hours to never find a single drop of blood, the arrow, or the bull. There’s not a doubt in my mind that the sound we heard was him falling. We just never located him.
I’ve killed about 15 animals with SEVRs. They haven’t impressed me. Blood trails always tended to be lacking in comparison to grim reapers (largely because of the 3 blades vs. 2). SEVRs aren’t very sharp from the factory and they’re a PIA to sharpen. The bull I lost probably wouldn’t have ever bleed that well from any broadhead given how high the shot was, but I still expected to find at least some blood.
If you’ve got the energy for a 1.75” SEVR you’ve got the energy for a 1.25 or 1.5” grim reaper fatal steel. I’ve killed somewhere in the neighborhood of 30 animals with grim reapers. Maybe close to 40, they’re by and large my favorite mechanical. The slogan “watch them drop” has been my overwhelming experience from shooting them at game.